In early March, a resident appeared before the Board of Selectmen upset about proposed food trucks in his neighborhood. High on his list of complaints was that nobody, he said, told him about the proposal.
“This was done without consulting the residents who will be directly affected by their decision,” wrote Marty Yaseen in a letter to the Brookline TAB following the meeting.
Yaseen was partially right; the town didn’t contact him about the proposal. They didn’t have to.
That’s because he’s a renter, and state laws and town regulations only require officials to contact property owners abutting a given project or licensing matter. While owners get a letter keeping them in the loop, renters like Yaseen have to rely on their landlords, or other means of gathering information to find out what’s going on.
“We’ve struggled with this issue,” said Jeff Levine, director of Planning and Community Development. “I don’t know of any community that notifies renters in Massachusetts.”
It’s a problem that’s perplexed the town for years. Officials said there’s just no easy way to directly notify tenants. And that void means there’s the potential for tenants to be disenfranchised in a given process.
While tenant notification isn’t particularly pertinent in areas of town where the majority of residents are property owners, large swaths of North Brookline are lined with apartment buildings.
Officials said they aren’t intentionally keeping tenants in the dark. In fact, they take several steps beyond state laws to try and make their notification processes as inclusive as possible. These often include the use of email lists where residents can sign up for meeting notifications, and deputizing neighborhood groups and Town Meeting members to spread the word.
But the fact remains that property owners have a leg up on the notification process. They get the letter first; they don’t need to rely on anybody else to stay informed.
A tenants’ rights advocate in Boston said the lack of laws requiring tenant notification means tenants are often left behind.
“This is a huge issue,” said Kathy Brown, coordinator for the Boston Tenant Coalition. “In some cases [tenants] would be more impacted than the owner, because the owner might live out of the neighborhood.”
Brown should know; she said she’s spent years going door to door with leaflets trying to get tenants to come to community meetings so they’re represented alongside owners in the conversation. If they began receiving the mailings, she thinks far more would turn out.
Levine said tenant notification has been a problem for the town since the end of rent control. That was the last time the town maintained a list of renters. Adding to the difficulty is the fact that renters are often transient, he said.
“We’ve struggled with how could you could find a good list of renters,” he said adding that he’s worked with community members to try and solve the problem in the past. “We didn’t find the silver bullet.”
The problem is that many of the possible solutions are incomplete, difficult or expensive.
One option he’s considered is posting placards on an affected property. That’s something required in Cambridge for certain zoning cases. The placards would include information about hearing dates and the like.
“That’s something that we explored in the past,” he said, adding that a downside is the placards could be taken or blow away. “I think for larger projects we should look at it, I don’t think we would want to do it for every single project.”
Not to mention the added workload and cost for his department, which is already burdened by funding woes.
“I am concerned about us keeping our head above of water,” he said. “I’m not excited about having a new huge administrative burden on the department.”
But Joe Ross, a longtime Town Meeting member, said he doesn’t buy it. He thinks the town would find a way to do it they were serious about informing renters.
“I think they are all excuses. I think if they decided they were going to do it they would do it,” he said. “They just don’t want to be bothered.”
Ross said he thinks the town could figure out the addresses of the town’s apartments and send the mailings out addresses whether they know who lives there or not.
“It’s not perfect, but they have the ability to do it,” he said.
While town officials said something like that might be possible, Levine said it’s unclear whether the costs would be worth the benefit. While the town does see instances where tenants complain about notification, he says property owners complain just as often about not getting the letters.
“It’s an additional cost,” he said. “As a result, we may go to all this effort and find that we’re still not reaching people for whatever reasons.”
And, he said, he kind of feels like if residents want to know what’s going on around them there are already ways to find out. In a sense, he thinks they have a responsibility to pay attention — to remain civically engaged.
“At the end of the day, being in a democracy does require participation,” he said. “It’s a two-way street.”
But Ross said that’s not always possible.
“Its just not an answer,” he said. “I try to very hard to know what’s going on in town but that doesn’t mean I know everything.”
FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.