Suit Filed Against Neighborhood Blitz Program

Thursday, September 10, 2015
Joe Goldeen
Stockton Record

“They’re doing this Nazi blitz thing. If they had come in with respect, it would have been very different.”

That’s how Michelle Holland, a four-year resident of north Stockton’s Gateway Apartments, recalled last winter’s city-sanctioned Neighborhood Blitz by Stockton code enforcers and police officers who, she said Thursday, gave her and her husband little choice but to allow them inside their two-story apartment.

A two-year resident said after the code enforcement team left her family’s apartment, her mother was left bruised by rough handling and the family’s valuable Elvis Presley memento was broken.

“They didn’t tell me what they were looking for,” said Chelsey Behling, 19.

Nine of Behling and Holland’s neighbors are the lead plaintiffs in a civil rights class-action lawsuit against the city filed this week in U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California in Sacramento.

In addition to the city, the suit filed by Oakland-based attorney Yolanda Huang names as defendants the Police Department, City Manager Kurt Wilson, Police Chief Eric Jones, Gateway Apartments owners Ravi, Manita and Mooni Sanwal, and several other city employees.

Among the suit’s allegations are that the tenants’ Fourth Amendment rights against search and seizure were violated; that they were specifically targeted by the city based upon their race, class and disability; and that their 14th Amendment rights to equal protection under the law were disregarded.

The suit identifies the nine plaintiffs as Carmen Slaughter, Alicia Carr, Larry Liebelt, Maria Luisa Cortez, Michelle Jordan, Shirly Feria, Richard Sykes, Brittani Silva and Calvin King, all tenants of either 20 Gateway Court, 23 Gateway Court or 39 Gateway Court.

Holland, 48, who is married to Liebelt, said Thursday his health precluded him from speaking about the case. He suffers from seizures often brought on by stress, and monthly visits by code enforcement since the initial Blitz operation have contributed to his stress level.

“We’re private people. When they first showed up, they gave us the option on paper to enter. But they said you have to let us in or we will get a warrant, and you will have to pay for the warrant,” Holland said.

“I thought it was fishy,” said Holland, who later learned that she would not have to pay for the city to obtain a warrant and learned from other neighbors that Blitz team members used other methods to get into residents’ apartments.

“They just followed (one man) in bringing in his groceries. They got into other people’s houses through their kids answering the door.”

A tenant who did not want to be identified out of fear of eviction said, “The managers threatened that if we didn’t let the city in, we would be evicted. The city needed to see proof that things were fixed or else the owners would be fined.”

The suit claims “police officers and employees engaged in a wholesale, systematic, unjustified and wrongful harassment and intimidation of poor and low-income tenants, many of whom are African-American or Hispanic, some of whom are physically disabled. These wrongful actions are part of an intentionally nasty, punitive and wholly unjustified tactic of the Stockton police and part of the police strategy to target low-income people, racially profile, and deny low-income people, people with disabilities and people of color, their constitutional rights, under the guise of housing code inspections.”

The inspections took place during daylight hours as well as “when people were sitting down to supper, or in the evening, when people were putting children to bed,” the suit says.

Since the Blitz operation, the plaintiffs have noticed that fellow tenants have moved out, leaving many apartments vacant. This has led to nontenants trespassing, squatting in the empty units and engaging in criminal activity, including gambling, drug dealing and prostitution.

The rent-paying tenants now are afraid of going outside or letting their children play outside, the suit claims.

The plaintiffs want their suit to be certified as a class action; the city to halt all further Neighborhood Blitz operations; and recognition that their constitutional rights have been violated. They are seeking unspecified damages from the city, certain named individuals and the apartment owners, as well as attorney’s fees for the costs of the suit.

Attorney Leora Perkowski, representing the Sanwal family, said Thursday neither she nor her clients would have a comment at this time because they have not seen a copy of the lawsuit. They might comment at a later date.

The Sanwals, who have owned the Gateway Apartments for approximately 12 years, previously filed a claim against the city over the loss of revenue they said they have endured following last winter’s Neighborhood Blitz inspections.

Said City Hall spokeswoman Connie Cochran: "We are not in a position to comment on pending litigation."

Huang, the attorney for the tenants, did not return a phone call seeking comment.

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: