In parody media source The Onion’s version on YouTube, a somber news
anchor intones: “The nation’s anti-tobacco lobby won another victory
today when Congress passed legislation restricting smoking to a single
room in Iowa.”
Absurd? Sure. Yet restrictions on smokers continue.
In
Washington, as elsewhere, the battle over secondhand smoke is moving
from airplanes, bars and office buildings to an arena that once seemed
impenetrable: private residences.
Next month, Tacoma-Pierce County
Health Board members will consider a proposal to classify secondhand
smoke as a “nuisance” in multi-unit housing.
The proposal, which backers want inserted into the state’s
landlord-tenant law, is one of dozens of attempts in communities around
the country to extend no-smoking restrictions from public places to
rental housing.
“This is the last piece of the puzzle that needs
to be placed,” said Nan Hogan of University Place, who helped write the
proposed legislation. “We’ve got smoke-free motel rooms, smoke-free
restaurants, smoke-free bars, smoke-free office buildings and even
prisons. Why should we go home and have to breathe it there?”
Hogan
is a member of the Pierce County group PUSH, for People United for
Smoke-free Housing. They point out that in most multi-family structures
there is no practical way to seal one apartment from another.
Smoke
seeps through walls, around doors and through electrical outlets.
Shared ventilation systems circulate the same air throughout all units
without adequately filtering it.
PUSH isn’t asking the Board of
Health to make any special rules in Pierce County. The group wants the
board to pass the proposal, so PUSH then can use it as ammunition in its
effort for a statewide law change during the next legislative session.
According
to the state Department of Health, 86 percent of renters in Washington
prefer smoke-free housing, including more than half of people who smoke.
Also, the Health Department says, every year in Washington about
500 children younger than age 5 get asthma from breathing secondhand
smoke.
Smokers’ rights advocates tend to regard efforts to control
smoking in rental apartments as unnecessary and an assault on private
rights.
“This is political correctness run amok,” said Gary
Nolan, U.S. director of the Citizens Freedom Alliance, which advocates
for smokers’ rights. “They’re taking away the rights of the landlord. We
have a republic, and they’re telling this guy what he can do with his
private property. These people should be ashamed of themselves.”
Landlords
have the right to declare their apartments smoke-free if they want to,
Nolan said, and that’s the way things should remain.
“They can say
on their own, ‘No smoking in any of our buildings,’” he said. “The free
market has a way of working these things out.”
Nolan acknowledges
that efforts to control smoking in apartments are gaining ground.
Nationally, 27 local jurisdictions have passed ordinances limiting or
prohibiting smoking altogether in multi-unit rentals, including eight
cities in California.
Hogan said she was moved to join the cause by personal experience.
She
and her husband lived for years in a West End Tacoma apartment building
overlooking the Tacoma Narrows. Their lives changed, Hogan said, when a
chain smoker moved into the apartment below them.
Hogan, who is 73 and has a history of bronchial problems, started wheezing.
“I
had never even heard the term ‘secondhand smoke’ until then,” she said.
“What astounded me was there was nothing I could do about it.”
PUSH
wants to change the state’s landlord-tenant law by defining secondhand
smoke as a nuisance. Destroying landlords’ property, engaging in gang
activity and using drugs already are considered nuisances under the law.
In
the scenario PUSH envisions, tenants bothered by smoke would follow the
procedures already in place for other nuisances: If tenants create a
nuisance, the landlord can give them three days’ notice to move out. If
they don’t move, the landlord can go to court and start an eviction
process.
The Tacoma-Pierce County Health Department and its board,
which will look at the proposal at a study session Sept. 15, have
historically taken the lead on anti-smoking issues.
The former Health Department director, Dr. Federico Cruz-Uribe, was an evangelist on the subject.
With
the support of the health board, Cruz-Uribe banned most outside
advertising of tobacco products in 1996, then created a furor in 2003 by
banning smoking in most indoor public places, including the county’s
bars, restaurants and bowling alleys.
The Washington State Supreme
Court threw out Pierce County’s ban, but two years later it became the
model for a successful statewide indoor smoking initiative.
The
eight-member health board, which is made up primarily of City of Tacoma
and Pierce County council members, sets broad public health policy for
the city and county. The Health Department director reports to the
board.
The department’s current director, Dr. Anthony Chen, is
proceeding cautiously. He supports the idea of smoke-free apartments,
but with some trepidation.
Reducing smoking is a huge priority for the Health Department, Chen said.
“Smoking
is the No. 1 cause of death and is associated with just about every
cancer known,” he said. “The effects of secondhand smoke are
well-documented.”
But he worries that legislation that is not thoroughly thought out could have unintended consequences.
He
said it could unfairly effect low-income people and minorities, groups
more likely to be smokers and also more likely to be renters. He also
worries that apartment owners could be hurt financially.
“Particularly in this economy, that could end up having a negative impact on the overall health of the community,” Chen said.
The
social justice argument does not sway Scott Neal, manager of the
tobacco-use prevention program at Public Health-Seattle & King
County.
“Whenever the topic of smoke-free housing comes up, you
always have somebody bring up that argument,” Neal said. “The way we
look at it is, that’s actually a good thing.”
The fact that smokers are more likely to be renters means this is a good way to reach them, he said.
“We
know that creating smoke-free environments helps people quit smoking,”
he said. “When a landlord creates a smoke-free apartment, it doesn’t
mean that people have to be evicted. It just means they have to alter
their behavior.”
And, while some apartment owners worry about
losing tenants or having to enforce no-smoking rules, others
enthusiastically support new smoke-free rules.
In a 2007 survey of
apartment owners and managers conducted by the Tacoma-Pierce County
Health Department, 82 percent of respondents said a smoke-free policy
would provide positive benefits. The top three benefits were decreased
cleaning costs, less cigarette trash on the property and less risk of
fire.
Smoke-free apartments are cheaper to clean between tenants,
they say; carpets and curtains don’t have to be replaced, painting needs
doing less often.
“If a smoker lived in a place, you can do as
much cleaning as you want, but there’s still the scent of smoke inside
of it,” said Chelsea Tornga, manager of the 40-unit Oasis Apartments on
Delin Street in Tacoma. “The residue from smoke sticks to the walls, so
you have to repaint. The smell stays in the carpets.”
Smokers are a leading cause of apartment fires, so owners’ liability insurance premiums often go down when they go smoke-free.
Seattle
and King County have taken a collaborative approach rather than
adopting any sort of “thou-shalt” position on apartment smoking, Neal
said.
One of their most effective tools, he said, is education.
“A
lot of landlords think no-smoking policies are illegal,” Neal said. “We
let them know that’s not the case. Making their property smoke-free is a
decision that’s entirely up to them; it’s like a pet policy.”
When
tenants call the Health Department to complain about smokers in their
building, Neal said, public health workers visit the landlord, carrying
educational material.
“We take as much information as we can,” he
said. “We even have a booklet that talks landlords through the process
of establishing smoke-free housing.”
The point is not getting smokers to leave, Neal said; it’s getting them to quit smoking.
“What
we tell landlords is, when you go smoke-free, make sure you have the
support there for the people who do want to quit,” he said. “You don’t
want to leave them hanging.”