Tax-Credit Dispute Jeopardizes Curtis Park Village

Tuesday, June 3, 2014
Brian van der Meer
Sacramento Business Journal

The developer of Curtis Park Village says his high-profile infill project is at risk because local housing authorities are improperly shifting affordable-housing tax credits to another effort.

In a pair of letters sent to the city last week, an attorney for Petrovich Development Co. said the city of Sacramento faces legal action if it doesn’t immediately order the Sacramento Housing and Redevelopment Agency to drop pursuit of a proposed allocation of tax credits to an existing affordable housing rehabilitation project in midtown. The developer says the city already committed to requesting those credits for its project adjacent to Curtis Park.

The City Council is scheduled to discuss the dispute in closed session Thursday. But there are indications the city could be sued no matter what it does.

Petrovich counsel Kenneth King, in a May 29 letter to the city, acknowledges that the agency has entered into agreements with nonprofit Bridge Housing of San Francisco, which is proposing the midtown project. But problems with the deal “are so serious that the city would be a party to fraudulent activity if it permitted SHRA to proceed.”

In an earlier letter, King said his company was counting on the tax credits. Not only had the city committed its support, but Petrovich took on a legal obligation to build an affordable-housing component within Curtis Park Village in connection with $9.1 million in Proposition 1C funds that it received.

Domus Development, which is building the affordable-housing project — called Curtis Park Court — on behalf of Petrovich, applied last year for 9-percent tax credits from the California Tax Credit Allocation Committee, with the City Council directing SHRA to make the project the city’s top priority.

After Domus didn’t receive the credits, the company applied again this year, again with a city vote to make it a priority. But King says the SHRA in the meantime had begun working with Bridge Housing on applying for those same tax credits for rehabbing the SHRA-operated Sutterview affordable housing project at 2526 L Street.

Meea Kang of Domus Development said SHRA, which is in the middle of a program to leverage funding for rehabilitation of much of its affordable housing inventory, is in a unique position as both a lender to affordable housing projects, and, in this case, a competitor to projects like Curtis Park Court.

But both Kang and King say Sutterview is a less-worthy project — in part because the Sutterview project will only rehabilitate, rather than create, affordable housing.

According to a source familiar with the situation, SHRA officials wanted to submit both projects for tax credits, but because Bridge Housing’s project scores higher under the criteria the allocation committee uses, it likely would receive them over Curtis Park Court. As well, Bridge officials have threatened legal action if that firm’s application is withdrawn, leaving the city with legal exposure either way, the source said.

Without the tax credits, according to King’s letter, Curtis Park Court won’t be finished by a deadline of December 2016, leaving Petrovich responsible for reimbursing the $9.1 million. In turn, that would lead to a default on $41 million worth of loans, and equity losses of about $35 million, the May 29 letter states.

The Sacramento City Council is scheduled to discuss the issue at Thursday’s meeting in closed session, while the tax credit allocation committee is scheduled to award tax credits -- of which only a finite amount are given out annually -- within the next two weeks.

Neither officials from the housing agency or Bridge Housing returned calls seeking comment. Darryl Rutherford, executive director of the Sacramento Housing Alliance, said while he hesitated to take sides in the dispute, the high stakes involved in receiving tax credits speaks to the difficulty of building affordable housing.

“The larger issue I see is Sacramento failing to give lower-income residents opportunities by providing enough affordable housing,” Rutherford said. “We’re going to see more of these challenges,” he added, given the end of redevelopment and fewer federal dollars available for affordable housing developers.

If it provides new units, Rutherford said, he’d favor Curtis Park Court as a project. “The challenge is whether it’s being done in an open and transparent way.”

Kang, too, said beyond the legal issues, she’s concerned about the city’s policy toward affordable housing.

“We’re looking about deeper affordability issues,” she said, noting for all the talk of adding new housing downtown, relatively little is slated to be affordable and none for the very poor or extremely poor. “There does need to be a balance. We have to look at the housing policy for the city overall.”

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.  

Help build power for renters' rights: