When The Pinnacle Group purchased the building where Kim Powell and her
family were living in 1997, she and her family hoped their 19 years of
housing woes might finally come to an end. Their dispute with the
building's former owner had ended with a victory: a judge ordered their
rent reduced $53 per month until necessary repairs were made. All they
needed now was for Pinnacle to comply with that order, which is exactly
what Powell says the company didn't do.
Not only would Pinnacle
resist the order for the next 12 years – raising her rent to $705 and
suing her for failing to pay it – they would also delay repairs and
frequently fail to supply heat and hot water, according to a lawsuit
that Powell and eight fellow tenants filed against the company in 2007.
The company even installed three feet from Powell's door a device,
Powell believed, to spy on her. The device consisted of an electrical
junction box with a hole drilled in the face place.
“It leaves a
bitter taste on my family’s mouth since we had to deal with this so
long," Powell says. "We spent a lot of mental energy in them coming to
us and saying can we start anew and us extending our hand to them, only
to be slapped one more time.”
Powell’s experience was not a
series of isolated incidents, advocates say, but a classic case of
predatory equity, a common landlord scheme that they hope will soon be
restricted by the Pinnacle tenants' landmark lawsuit. In the scheme,
real estate investors buy rent-controlled or stabilized buildings, then
pressure the tenants – primarily through harassment and failing to make
repairs – to vacate them. After a tenant leaves, the landlord rents or
sells the vacant unit at a higher price.
"These hedge-fund
backed landlords that acquired huge numbers of subprime apartments
gambled on their ability to raise rents and evict low-income tenants,"
says Edward Josephson, director of litigation at South Brooklyn Legal
Services. "Either the gamble pays off and they displace tenants or they
don't succeed and their business model collapses."
The crash of
the housing market in 2007 has already reduced the prevalence of
predatory equity in New York City, but a tenant victory in the Pinnacle
lawsuit would help ensure that when the market rebounds, the practice
doesn’t. And this month, the prospect of such a victory grew brighter
when a judge granted the plaintiffs class action status. Pinnacle owns
over 420 apartment buildings in New York City, containing more than
21,000 apartments and 60,000 tenants. Gaining class action status will
enable potentially thousands of current and former Pinnacle tenants to
join the plaintiffs' case.
The Rent Stabilization Association,
which represents property owners, said it’s too early to comment on the
significance of the case. “It’s way too soon to know what impact it
has” says spokesperson Frank Ricci. “We have to see the merits of the
case. Right now it’s a very esoteric case, a very specific fact pattern
with a very specific owner.”
Indeed, the case could drag on for
several more years while the tenant’s attorneys labor to prove their
case. The lawsuit alleges that Pinnacle and its chief executive Joel
Weiner not only violated the New York Consumer Protection Act and rent
stabilization laws and codes, but acted as a “criminal enterprise”
under the Federal Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act
(RICO), a law enacted to fight organized crime. That law applies to
landlords who engage in predatory equity because, similar to an
organized crime syndicate, they scheme to violate the law to make a
profit, says Sateesh Nori, an attorney with the Legal Aid Society who
has clients residing in Pinnacle buildings.
Proving that
Pinnacle violated RICO will be the most difficult part of the case,
because it will require plaintiffs to show that the company and Weiner
engaged in a deliberate pattern of racketeering by violating over a 10
year period at least two of 35 crimes under the statute.
The
other problem plaintiffs might face is convincing more tenants to
participate, Powell says. In 2006, Pinnacle filed eviction proceedings
against about 5,000 tenants. Since the plaintiffs filed suit, Powell
contends, Pinnacle’s harassment and intimidation of tenants has
worsened. “The massive fear that is being kicked out of your home,”
says Powell. “What is perturbing to me even today, I have reason to
believe, despite the signing of the settlement agreement they continued
to conduct illegal practices.”
But if the plaintiffs succeed in
obtaining an adverse judgment against Pinnacle, the company could lose
billions of dollars. The judge could order the company to reimburse up
to three times the rent it overcharged. Additionally, the state’s
Division of Housing and Community Renewal can penalize landlords $250
for deliberate violations of rent regulations and $2,500 when it finds
them guilty of harassing tenants to vacate apartments.
“I think
if the plaintiffs prevail in Pinnacle, the precedent will create a
strong additional disincentive for landlords to engage in broad
predatory practices," says Josephson. "In fact, just the fact that the
Pinnacle case has progressed as far as it has, has probably given
landlords some food for thought."
The case is not the first to
allege that landlords violated RICO laws, nor is it the first filed
since the City Council passed the tenant anti-harassment law in 2008.
But Josephson believes it could be the first time in New York City
history that tenants have won class action status in a case filed under
RICO.
Attorneys for the plaintiffs have set up a hotline for
tenants with complaints against Pinnacle, and the Manhattan Borough
President’s Office is recruiting tenant advocates in the 194 Pinnacle
buildings in Manhattan to get more tenants involved in the lawsuit.
Powell
recalls that when tenants in her building, 706 Riverside Drive in West
Harlem, first began to realize that their problems with Pinnacle were
systemic, their only option was to file a complaint with DHCR.
Now
the court will have the opportunity to consider the impact on every
alleged Pinnacle victim, Powell says. “While I sat back there in 1997,
while I saw what I saw, I wasn’t able to articulate it 'til 2005, other
than to say I saw something that was potentially terribly wrong,” she
says. “I just needed to get someone to listen. I think we have that
now.”
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.