Tenants demand fairness in face of pending rent hikes

Wednesday, August 24, 2011
Ian Bauer
MercuryNews.com

Residents of Friendly Village Mobilehome Estates crammed into Milpitas City Hall's Council Chambers last week, outraged about a proposed 50- to nearly 90-percent rental increase they say will force many of them from their homes at 120 Dixon Landing Road.

Several Friendly Village residents, who spoke during the meeting's public forum, implored Milpitas City Council to intervene in the rent increase, just as the council was set to appoint three new members to Milpitas' Mobile Home Park Rental Review Board.

"For what they're asking for is a five-star mobile home park, and it's not a five-star mobile home park," resident Toni Perrina told the council of the rent increase, adding most Friendly Village residents lived on limited, fixed incomes. "That needs to be forefront in the minds of this company."

Santiago Communities Inc., the Southern California-based owner of Friendly Village, stated in documents sent to Friendly Village residents in late June that their rents would rise to $875 per month Oct. 1. The documents indicate rents would increase up to 1.41 percent per month due to a rise in the Bay Area's consumer price index the measure of the average change over time in prices paid by consumers for goods and services.

"The rents are going up because the rents are below market, they're more than $200 below market," Anthony C. Rodriguez, an Oakland lawyer representing Santiago Communities, told Milpitas Post this week.

Saying that Santiago Comm-unities is entitled to raise rents each year, Rodriguez noted that his firm sent a June 30 letter to the city council requesting an amendment to the city's rent control ordinance that proposed City of Milpitas publicly subsidize part of the rent about $270 a month for qualifying Friendly Village residents toward meeting the increased rents.

"...My client does not believe the City of Milpitas can require it to offer mobile home spaces at below market rates in perpetuity," the letter reads. "Accordingly, rather than attempting to force park owners to subsidize a select group of tenants for all time, my client respectfully requests the City of Milpitas to adopt its own subsidy program, whereby tenants at the Milpitas mobile home parks may obtain a grant from the City of Milpitas, for the difference between the Ôrent control rate' and the Ôfair market rate.'"

Rodriguez said Friendly Village residents may also qualify for a park owners' rent credit program, which would excuse them from paying the rent increase if their income is less than $2,625 per month.

Still, Friendly Village residents such as Rosemary Wood said any rental increase will be too high for them to pay.

"We just kind of struggle along," Wood told the council, adding the increase "scared the living day lights" out of her when she found out about it in June.

"It' not worth the money they're asking," said Wood as her rent would go from about $600 to $875, a 50 percent increase. "Can't afford it. I'm going to have to move out of the area; it's a pretty desperate situation."

Some residents said they had lived for years in what they claimed were poorly maintained facilities.

"It caught my house on fire," Gerry Knight said of electrical wiring attached to a meter that she claimed caused a $9,000 blaze that damaged her mobile home three years ago.

Knight also claimed Santiago Communities took no responsibility for that fire as the meter disappeared after the incident, in what she believed was a way to eliminate evidence for fire investigators.

"That's the type of stuff that we put up with at Friendly Village," Knight said.

Others alleged additional problems at Friendly Village. They said residents have to swim in an unkempt pool as well watch for uneven driveway pavement near mobile homes that can cause falls.

During the meeting, talk of conditions at Friendly Village caused Councilman Armando Gomez the city council liaison to the Mobile Home Park Rental Review Board to say the city would not tolerate any property owners acting like a "slumlord."

"They need to be held accountable," Gomez said.

Later, city staff noted Friendly Village residents filed a petition with the city to schedule a hearing in front of the Mobile Home Park Rental Review Board. City staff suggested any decision on this issue would only come from that body.

Milpitas City Manager Tom Williams said that meeting date has not been set, but would be held before Sept. 28.

According to attorney Rodriguez, the Friendly Village site is a safe, clean and well-run mobile home community.

Rodriguez added, however, that following last week's council meeting the Milpitas Building and Safety Department showed up at Friendly Village to perform property inspections.

"It's a retaliatory strike on the city's part," Rodriguez said.

Rodriguez also objected to Councilman Gomez's use of the term "slumlord."

"It's pretty outrageous that a council member would call my client a Ôslumlord,'" Rodriguez said. "It's hardly a slum; it's a very well maintained property. That councilman should be ashamed of himself; that's outrageous that a neutral council member would make such a statement."

Rodriguez said in his experience many mobile home park residents facing rental increases are "willing to make up all kinds of stories."

"It's unfortunate people will make up false stories in order to get fee discounts on their rent," Rodriguez said.

He added Santiago Communities would consider not raising rental fees on those tenants who could prove via documentation that they had a drop in their personal income and could not afford the new rent.

"All they have to do is prove it, and they won't have to pay the rent increase," Rodriguez said.

After the meeting, resident Dolores Hovey said the $875 flat rent would not be all that Friendly Village residents will need to pay.

"We have a mortgage, homeowners' insurance, we have to pay property tax and then we have to pay rent on top of that," she said.

A Friendly Village resident since 1987, Hovey added in the early 1990s Santiago Communities had tried, but failed to raise the rents at the mobile home park as the city imposed its rent control laws.

"We'd not have rent control in Milpitas if Santiago had not done it in the (1990s)," Hovey said, adding her main concern was that nobody lose their home in the latest proposed increase. "It's really a very emotional time. As far as I'm concerned it's corporate greed; I just don't understand it especially with the economy right now."

After the meeting, City of Milpitas staff would not comment about the Friendly Village matter, stating the issue would be reviewed by the city's Mobile Home Park Rental Review Board a council-appointed group founded in 1992 to review rent increase petitions on an as-needed basis.

City staff noted the Aug. 16 council meeting was only held to approve three of the board's newest members residents Huy Bui, Dem Nitafan and alternate Mila Garcia and was not meant to discuss the Friendly Village rent increase.

City Manager Williams said that whatever the Mobile Home Park Rental Review Board decides, the matter could still be heard again at a higher level.

"Any decisions by the board are appealable to the city council," Williams said.

FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together.  This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: