Tenants at the eight-story Marina View Towers will be forced to leave their apartments next month while the new owners perform maintenance to the building.
San Francisco real estate firm, Carmel Partners, notified tenants purchased the building at 1100 Pacific Marina on May 22.
They then notified residents of the 84-unit apartment building they would be evicting tenants five weeks later on July 27. Tenants will have until Aug. 31 to leave the premises.
"A move, when it's planned, is traumatic enough," said Shelia James, a resident of the Marina View Towers since Feb. 2012. "But when it's not planned [it] is even more traumatic."
Carmel Partners said the force out is for "seismic retrofitting."
"We learned that Marina View Towers needs substantial seismic retrofitting," wrote the real estate firm after they completed a seismic study. "Our engineers informed us that the work cannot be completed while anyone occupies or lives in Marina View Towers."
James said she did not know the building needed any repairs.
"The previous owners nor the management company said anything about it," said James. "I know a guy that moved in in March and another guy who moved in in April. Now they have to move again."
James said her two biggest qualms with the eviction is she believes tenants forced to move out should receive some kind of compensation, and the grace period between when she received her notification letter and the eviction.
Apartment owners in San Francisco are required to compensate tenants of more than 12 months who have been forced to relocate for no-fault evictions under California Civil Code section 37.9. "Each eligible tenant receiving a covered no-fault eviction notice shall receive $4,500, $2,250 of which shall be paid at the time of the service of the notice to quit, and $2,250 of which shall be paid when the unit is vacated," according to part 1 of the section. Santa Monica, Los Angeles and Oakland have similar laws. James brought her displeasure to the council at last Tuesday's City Council meeting hoping they would pass a similar ordinance.
"It would benefit residents in Alameda if the city had this type of ordinance," said James. "When developers come into Alameda taking property off the market, it would make them think twice before displacing residents."
Carmel Partners notified James and other tenants on June 27 about the Aug. 31 apartment-wide eviction. This time period of 65 days is longer than the 60-day grace period apartment owners must give tenants between the time tenants are first notified and when they can be evicted under California Civil Code Section 1946.1 part b.
However, owners must provide 120 days of notice under the California Ellis Act if the eviction is to "change the use" of the building. This happens mostly when owners change apartment buildings to condominiums.
"If you look at their web site, most of their apartments are all luxury apartments or condos," said James.
However, in the notification letter, Carmel Partners states, "the owner's desire to complete this necessary seismic retrofitting is the owner's sole cause for terminating your vacancy."
James and other tenants are now left to pick up the pieces. The building is scheduled to reopen sometime in the summer of 2014 — James signed up for a hold on one of the apartments, but is unsure if she will move in. For now, James has purchased a home in Stockton because she could not find a place in Alameda that fits her needs and was in her price range. Numerous tenants in the building will be holding a "kick out sale" this Saturday. For more information, see page 8.
Phone calls to Carmel Partners were not returned.
FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.