Tenants in 'Worst Landlords' Bronx Buildings Take Wall Street — Not Their Landlord — to Court

Wednesday, April 21, 2010
Elizabeth Dwoskin
Village Voice

On the heels of the Voice's "10 Worst Landlords" series, tenants in 10 foreclosed buildings in the Bronx run into the ground by dishonoree Milbank Real Estate are going to court with a new strategy that directly targets Wall Street.

Backed up by local pols, they're asking a judge today to force
mortgage-holder Wells Fargo itself to take direct responsibility for,
and shell out millions to fix, nearly 4,500 housing code violations.

The buildings are in foreclosure proceedings in Bronx Supreme
Court after Milbank, run by L.A. brothers Aaron and Solyman Yashouafar,
defaulted early last year on a $35 million mortgage. A court-appointed
receiver is operating the buildings. But they have slid further into
decay, say sources close to the situation, because Wells Fargo isn't
forking up the cash to maintain them even at their previously poor
level.

"The Milbank tenants have suffered the consequences of Wall Street's reckless lending practices
for too long," Jonathan Levy, deputy director of the Legal Services-NYC
Bronx Housing Unit, says. "The lenders must be held accountable for the
costs of repairing the damage."

Since the Voice series (Part 1, which includes Milbank; Part 2), the Times and heavyweight politicians have hopped on board to support the Milbank tenants' new strategy.

City Council Speaker Christine Quinn, Bronx Borough President
Ruben Diaz Jr., and Council Member Fernando Cabrera conducted a press
conference today with the tenants, their advocates at the Urban Homesteading Assistance Board, and their lawyers.

The new strategy, in this case a motion that's part of the
foreclosure proceedings, could have wide-ranging impact on other
overextended landlords that were able to get loans from reckless banks.
If the court "holds the bank responsible," a Times story says,
"the move could discourage other banks from entering foreclosure
proceedings on other properties, leaving buildings to sink deeper into
limbo."

The Milbank buildings could hardly sink any deeper. The buildings are "unlivable," tenants say, and the Voice's own on-site inspection backs that up.

The mortgage holder is technically a $3 billion commercial
mortgage-backed security trust controlled by Wells Fargo and
loan-servicer LNR Partners Inc. After Milbank defaulted, the trust
started foreclosure proceedings. The Yashouafar brothers held the
buildings for barely two years before defaulting on their loan. They
also own other buildings in the Bronx.

A few months ago, Joe Cicciu, the court-appointed receiver, told the Voice,
"It's triage, you know? I almost feel like I'm on a battlefield with
the wounded coming in. Not everyone is shot up, sometimes these are
only flesh wounds. So we go to some of those apartments and try to fix
things, patch things up, to give people a chance to live in decent
apartments. But for people with the collapsing ceilings, we are trying
to relocate them into vacant units. The problem is, most of the vacant
units need a gut renovation! And we don't have the dollars for that
anymore."

This new court action doesn't name a dollar figure, but Cicciu previously told the Voice,
"If we're talking about bringing the buildings up to the quality that
they are supposed to be, then we're talking about tens of millions of
dollars."

FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. 

Help build power for renters' rights: