Nearly four years after City Attorney Dennis Herrera filed suit
against Frank and Walter Lembi and their dizzying array of companies
affiliated with CitiApartments for "an outrageous pattern of corporate
lawlessness," the powerful and notorious San Francisco landlords have
watched their empire crumble.
The Lembi empire consisted of more 300 apartment buildings in San
Francisco at its peak. Four Lembi subsidiaries that owned 16 buildings
filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in February. Twenty Lembi properties
were taken over by Lennar spin-off LNR in late May; another 24
buildings are slated to be foreclosed in early June; 51 were deeded
back to UBS bank in lieu of foreclosure early last year; and still
others are now held by court-appointed receivers and managed by
Laramar, an unaffiliated property-management company.
CitiApartments still owns and manages a large portion of the
buildings it controlled in its heyday, but it's had to either
restructure loans or get payment extensions to hold onto many of them,
according to general counsel Ed Singer. The Lembi Group staff has
dwindled, and a team of 18 dedicated solely to relocating tenants is
now long gone.
For many renters in foreclosed units who managed to ride out what
San Francisco Tenants Union director Ted Guillicksen has labeled
CitiApartments' "war of terror" against its occupants, the dust has
finally settled. Gullicksen says that living in limbo is better than
living under Lembi.
There are no more harassing phone calls pressuring them to move. No
more sudden utility shutoffs. No armed agents showing up at the
doorstep unannounced. No illegal construction projects clamoring away
on the other side of paper-thin walls, destroying any hope of
tranquility at home.
These are tactics CitiApartments used to drive people out, according
Herrera's 2006 complaint and an award-winning Guardian series ("The
Scumlords," March 25), in order to vacate units so they could be
renovated and removed from rent control protections. A San Francisco
Rent Board roster of 174 current and former Lembi properties as of May
25 lists no fewer than 1,890 cases associated with those buildings, the
majority of them now settled.
While the sordid history of CitiApartments' strong-arm tactics has
been well-documented, tenant-rights advocates say the untold story of
the Lembis' rise and demise is that its entire business model hinged on
evicting and relocating existing tenants — but that strategy failed, in
large part because of a grassroots organizing effort that emboldened
renters to stand their ground.
"The economic downturn played a role in it because the money stopped
flowing," says Gullicksen, who helped form the CitiStop Campaign in
2004 in response to reports of outrageous tactics. "But if the money
kept flowing, I think they would have failed anyway. The end result was
inevitable, given the tenant resistance."
Darin Dawson moved into his apartment at 2 Guerrero St. in 1994 on a
lease secured through the federal Housing Opportunities for People With
AIDS program. Dawson, who was diagnosed in 1987, said things turned
sour in 1998 when Trophy Properties I DE LLC — one of the Lembis'
dozens of subsidiaries — snapped it up.
Their first contact was to inform him that he would have to move
"because we don't allow those kinds of leases in our buildings," he
recalled. He fought it with the help of the Housing Authority and
managed to stay put. It was the first in a series of standoffs that
ultimately stopped last September when the property was repossessed.
"Basically, I just dug my heels in and knew that I couldn't get
evicted," Dawson said. Nonetheless, he spent years embroiled in
conflict with the Lembi subsidiary while also battling AIDS-related
illnesses.
There was the time he was ordered to vacate his apartment for two
weeks during a seismic retrofit only to find it trashed when he
returned. "The floors were ripped up," he said. "The ceiling was
hanging in some places. There was black grease smeared all over the
walls." He repaired it himself. Then came the constant phone calls,
which started off artificially cheerful but turned threatening if he
refused to accept money to relocate.
Dawson pays a base amount of $635 per month for his rent-controlled
studio, so he suspected he might be a target. Once a residential
manager discreetly warned him that his name was on a "hit list" of
tenants whom the owners wanted gone, he said.
According to a confidential document leaked to advocates by an
anonymous source, tenants who paid the least came under the greatest
pressure to relocate since San Francisco rent-control laws prohibit
raising existing occupants' rents to market rate. The document outlines
how loan repayment and estimated profits were calculated wholly on the
expectation that existing tenants would vacate, rather than relying on
normal projections like natural turnover.
"Tenants with significantly below market rents are chosen for
thorough screening to see if they might be relocated," according to the
document, a 2008 Credit Suisse prospectus concerning a pool of 24
buildings under Lembi ownership that have since been foreclosed. "Those
tenants most below market and/or with the longest history are the
priority for relocation."
All 24 buildings in question — including properties on Larkin,
Market, Cesar Chavez, Post, and Leavenworth streets, in addition to
others — were subject to rent control. "At acquisition [Aug. 30, 2007],
the portfolio was approximately 5 percent vacant," it notes. "As of May
2008 the portfolio was 19 percent vacant, as a result of Lembi
successfully executing their business plan of vacating units and
rolling them to market."
Although the paperwork spelling this out in stark terms didn't
surface until recently, advocates who worked on the CitiStop campaign
essentially figured it out years ago. A collaboration between the
Tenants Union, Pride at Work, and other advocacy groups, the campaign
sent organizers door-to-door to inform tenants of their rights, hosted
potlucks where people could swap horror stories and forge alliances,
and staged demonstrations outside CitiApartments' Market Street offices.
They tracked public records from the Assessor-Recorder Office and
swooped in to warn tenants whose buildings had fallen into the Lembis'
clutches. It didn't always work. According to the Credit Suisse
document, Lembi had relocated 2,500 units as of August 2008, a fact
pointed to as evidence of its "successful track record." But the
relocation team only drove out a small number of the lowest-paying
tenants; the vast majority of those who took buyout offers left units
that paid closer to market rate.
"They really needed to get more turnover than what they
accomplished," Gullicksen said. "The fact that they couldn't is
attributable to the CitiStop campaign."
Singer rejected this assessment, saying the real problem was the
economic downturn and the loss of capital availability. "I can see why
they want to say that, why they want to take credit for bringing down
the Lembis," he said. "But I don't think it would have made any
difference if [tenants] left or not."
A common complaint nowadays is that former tenants haven't gotten
their security deposits back, a matter that has spurred a class-action
lawsuit against 57 corporate defendants associated with the Lembi Group.
"They're claiming that they have no money," Brian Devine, an
attorney with Seeger Salvas LLP, told the Guardian. Devine estimates
that he will end up representing several thousand tenants who are
entitled to their deposits. In March, a judge awarded sanctions of
$30,000 to Devine's firm because the Lembi Group refused to cooperate
with discovery, withholding documents necessary for the case to proceed.
Herrera has encountered a similar recalcitrance in his own suit and
won court sanctions of $50,000 in February for the same reason. "We
have been engaged in discovery for a long, long time," noted city
attorney spokesperson Matt Dorsey. "We're hoping that the judge is at
the edge of his patience."
Singer said the problem was that there wasn't enough "people power"
to photocopy thousands of documents. The Lembis were never up to any
nefarious purpose, Singer insisted — they only wanted to make the
buildings nicer. As for the tenants who endured the most brutal
relocation tactics? "I can understand why they didn't want to leave,"
he said. "Some of them didn't leave — and they're still there."
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.