Unlicensed trailer parks: Unsafe to stay, but nowhere else to go

Sunday, September 4, 2011
Marcel Honoré
MyDesert.com

For 14-year-old Jonathan Contreras, the worst part of living without power during triple-digit temperatures is trying to sleep.

He has had plenty of practice. A year ago this week, a strained electrical box caught fire. It supplied power to about half of the mobile homes in the park where Contreras and his family live.

The residents were without power — no air conditioning, fans, lights or refrigeration — for a month.

“You couldn't sleep,” said Contreras, a student at Toro Canyon Middle School. By the end of the school day, he grew tired and sluggish.

Life in the Hernandez mobile home park, in the 88-700 block of Avenue 62 near Thermal, hasn't improved much for Contreras and the 90 other residents in the past year.

Raw sewage bubbles into a vacant lot where an underground septic line appears to have burst, next to the mobile unit where Felipe Flores lives with his wife and their 10-month-old daughter.

The on-site well supplying drinking water has tested positive at least twice this year for potentially unsafe bacteria.

And late last month, a lingering heat wave again brought sporadic power outages over two days to the park as temperatures hovered around 110 degrees.

The persistent problems at the Hernandez park reflect similar circumstances at scores of small mobile home parks across the eastern Coachella Valley, many of them unlicensed and unregulated.

The parks, many in place for decades, house thousands of workers employed in the valley's $500 million agriculture industry and their families.

Most encampments grew from one or two ancient mobile homes or campers to a ragtag collection of shelters on private land.

In June, Riverside County code enforcement officials reported inspecting 63 east valley parks — including 823 housing units — as
part of a new push launched in 2008 to
clean up conditions.

But those inspections create a dilemma when extreme violations are found: shut down a park and leave people homeless, or let them remain in substandard, sometimes dangerous conditions.

“We know they're all in bad condition ... but we recognize reality out there,” said Meagan Beaman, a Coachella-based attorney with California Rural Legal Assistance, Inc. who is representing several Hernandez park residents.

Temporary fixes

Even when the county does act, enforcement is sporadic.

The fire in the electrical box at the Hernandez park was the catalyst for two lawsuits, one by the county, and a judge ordered that the park owners make living conditions there safe.

The electrical system was temporarily fixed, but no other improvements were made.

Felipe Flores said the seeping sewage next to his home has worsened in the past two weeks, but he has been unable to get the park's owners to do anything about it.

The recent outages had residents worried last week that another blackout was coming.

“I worried about the month we had last year,” Jonathan Contreras said this past Tuesday, his face sweaty in the sweltering afternoon heat. “I worry it's going to happen again.”

Paying for repairs

The meager rents collected at the smaller parks dotting the east valley's scrubby landscape often cannot cover the cost of repairs to bring plumbing and wiring up to code.

Most of the renters in the Hernandez park's 21 mobile units pay $200 a month in rent, plus utilities.

“Because it's a small park and the rents are so low, the income makes it an extreme challenge to fund the repairs that are necessary,” Beaman said.

The park's residents blocked attempts by the landlord last year to increase rent by $150 a month. Residents argued the hike was unfair since owners planned to close the park within a year and had yet to make any substantial electrical and sewage repairs.

The park's owners maintain the electrical repairs were adequate.

“There's no problem,” Silvia Hernandez, one of several siblings living in Coachella who own the park, said in a brief phone interview last week. Asked whether her family had received complaints about a new wave of outages, Hernandez declined to comment and hung up.

Last year, Hernandez told The Desert Sun there was no way her family could afford to pay for the permits and the scope of repairs demanded by county officials.

Legal action

California Rural Legal Assistance pushes for safer living conditions for farm and service-sector workers but also aims to ensure they don't lose their homes in the process, Beaman said.

The county filed suit against the Hernandez family last Oct. 19 to fix their park and get the proper permits. The suit's status is not clear from court records but a hearing is scheduled for Sept. 26.

Attorneys for Riverside County did not return calls for comment.

Court records indicate the Hernandez family does not have an attorney in the suit.

In January, the park's water well tested positive for “total coliform” — indicating there could be harmful bacteria in the water, according to Laurie Holk, supervising environmental health specialist with the county's environmental health department.

The department issued an order for the well to be cleaned, but the problem continues.

Two weeks ago, the latest water samples showed there's still coliform present. The owners must get a “certified operator” by Thursday who can clean the well, Holk said.

How long they have to clean the water depends on what the operator finds, she added. She didn't say what could happen if the well water isn't cleaned.

In the meantime, some residents refuse to drink the well water and buy bottled water instead.

Taking action

Last Tuesday, as local television news vans hummed behind him, Arcadio Ramirez fastened a colorful array of posters with messages in English and Spanish across the chain link fences at the Hernandez park.

One stated, “We want to live without fear.” It was almost identical to the scene at the park a year earlier, when residents held a news conference about their power outage to force the owners to make repairs.

Nearby, fans and air conditioning units pumped air into Ramirez's cramped living room as his wife, Elisa Guevara, sat recovering from what relatives described as kidney surgery in July.

Large bandages lined Guevara's stomach and a medical tube was inserted into her abdomen. During the recent power outage, many Hernandez park residents fled to nearby homes, but Guevara's condition left her unable to leave.

“My mom felt very bad,” Guevara's daughter, 5-year-old Yhamilée Ramirez, recounted. “She was very hot.”

A few feet away, Guevera winced, curled her feet and breathed heavily as family and friends talked around her.

Eduardo Guevara, Elisa's brother, explained she did not take her prescribed pain medication in order to stay lucid and to talk to neighbors and the news media outside her trailer.

A leader in the park, she is the head of a neighborhood committee dedicated to improve conditions.

A few minutes later, Elisa was wheeled outside in a chair and spoke in Spanish to her neighbors.

“For many years we've been invisible, but that's changing,” she told them.

“In lots of places, the people would rather stay quiet than fight,” Guevara said. “I'm proud to live in this park. These people came here for a better life, and that's what they're doing.”

FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together.  This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: