The promotional blurb for High Point Village, a development of 600 new homes at Hayes, on the fringes of west London,
claims it is a "thoroughly modern mix of affordable and luxury
accommodation ... carefully designed – engineered, almost – to offer an
oasis of calm in an otherwise busy, driven world, and to give its
residents a real sense of community that is sometimes lacking in more
anonymous city developments".
It's not quite how some of the residents in the development's "affordable" homes section view it. Those either in social housing
or in part-buy, part-rent accommodation claim they are treated as
second-class citizens, citing the internal gates that divide them from
their neighbours in the "luxury" housing blocks. There is even a gate in
the car park to divide the affordable residents from the other
homeowners.
Audrey Verma, who lives in one of the affordable
blocks, says High Point Village is "a gated community within which there
is another gate keeping the affordable community away from the private
community". Residents in affordable homes also point to on-site maps on
which private housing blocks are named, but the two blocks containing
affordable and social housing are left blank.
Tension
came to a head in August after a disruption to the water supply left
some residents in affordable homes without water for nearly two days.
Some residents found an emergency hosepipe existed for the private
homeowners only to be told it could not be used to temporarily supply
affordable homes. Families claim that at one point they were reduced to
filling up bottles from a decorative fountain at the entrance to the
luxury housing area.
"Many people here have been afraid to speak
out in the past because they were afraid it would affect the resale
value, but what happened with the water was beyond belief," says Verma.
"We are not even allowed to use the hosepipe. The gate has always been a
big issue because it separates the haves from the have-nots, but in
this case we were told it could not even be opened temporarily to run a
hose through."
Tensions rose further when residents claim they
were ejected from a Facebook page for High Point Village residents for
raising their concerns.
Mixed housing developments, a policy
initiative accelerated under the Labour government, are no strangers to
criticism. Developers have been accused of socially divisive tactics,
including providing only smaller units, such as one-bedroom flats, for
residents who cannot afford the luxury homes.
The local MP for
Hayes and Harlington, Labour's John McDonnell, says the original concept
for High Point Village was a mixed private and social housing site with
a range of community facilities available to all. "In its
implementation, High Point became a classic example of where a site has
been developed on the basis of isolating the social housing content of
the development into one corner and gating off access for social housing
tenants," he says. "The water supply breakdown is just the latest
example of the overall approach on the site which is a focus on
maximising profits from direct sales above all else."
Sarah Blandy, a law professor at the University of Sheffield who has studied gated communities, says developers are often required to provide a quota of affordable housing, whether gated or not, to gain planning consent.
"This
housing is often segregated from the 'private' housing, and visibly
different from it. The gating just makes this more obvious," Blandy
says. "Gating within gating is not uncommon, either – often ostensibly
for security reasons, to prevent any outsider/criminal who's managed to
gain access from being able to escape easily."
Construction on
High Point Village was started in 2007 by Ballymore Group, a major
player in the development of London's Docklands.
Thames
Valley Housing (TVH), which is involved in managing the development,
said: "The water outage at High Point Village has highlighted the
operational challenges of managing a mixed-tenure scheme, and we have
noted the concerns raised by the residents. A meeting is scheduled
between Directors at TVH and Ballymore to review this incident and the
management of the scheme more widely, to ensure a good service is
delivered to residents of all tenures."
Ballymore says it takes
great care with "all elements of mixed-use developments with integration
of affordable, private residential and commercial space whilst, as in
the case of High Point Village, also creating self-contained buildings
for ease of management of the affordability of service charges".
It
points out that the "affordable" homes at High Point also have a secure
gated garden with a playground and that the pool is open to all
residents.
Adrian Gill, chairman of the High Point Village
Residents Association, said members had realised the association only
represented residents of three blocks. This was not down to social exclusion, but because of restrictions by legislation governing the running and recognition of residents associations, he said.
"The
difficulties we face within the development are, I think, a consequence
of increasingly dense housing development – necessitated by the rapidly
expanding population here in London – and simplistic and naive planning
policy on the part of councils."The key to making this work lies in
removing physical barriers that have the effect of segregating residents
with different tenure, and therefore fostering social stigma."
FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.