In Avondale, Tawana Riley battles daily with roaches, bed bugs and faulty electrical outlets.
In Over-the-Rhine, residents at The Senate Apartments on 12th Street have been plagued by a rat infestation and broken plumbing that backs up sewage.
And in Walnut Hills, Alexander Bailey has struggled for three years to keep water from leaking into his apartment when it rains. "Something has to be done," says Bailey. "We're paying the rent every month and the government is paying, but nothing is getting done. Where is all the money going?"
Their homes are among nearly 700 units of low-income housing across Cincinnati left to crumble after their owners, Brooklyn-based NY Group, bought them three years ago and then fell into foreclosure in July 2010.
Purchased at the peak of the housing market for $21.5 million, the 19-building portfolio of affordable rental housing spans nine Cincinnati neighborhoods and includes apartment communities in Evanston, Mount Auburn, Paddock Hills, East Price Hill and Sedamsville.
The case illustrates how the impact of nation's foreclosure crisis is spreading beyond over-leveraged homeowners and into the country's most fragile housing stock: low-income rental communities that were purchased at peak of the market by speculators and investors.
Residents say major problems began at their homes after NY Group took over in 2007. Since the foreclosure filing, repairs to the buildings have become the responsibility of lending giant Fannie Mae, the mortgage holder for the financially ailing properties.
The lender says it has spent hundreds of thousands of dollars to address outstanding code violations and city work orders that went unattended to under the NY Group's watch.
But residents and others say the buildings remain in unacceptably poor condition.
"The NY Group was not interested in making repairs and neither is Fannie Mae, it appears," said Marcheta Gillam, a lawyer at the Legal Aid Society of Greater Cincinnati.
For Riley, Bailey and the 653 other Cincinnati families renting from the NY Group, foreclosure means an uncertain future; there's no guarantee they can stay in their homes once they are sold.
The case also begs the question of who is protecting taxpayers.
As federally subsidized low-income apartments, the NY Group properties receive monthly rental payments from residents and the government. Tenants pay 30 percent of their income toward rent; taxpayers pick up the balance.
Last month, for example, Riley paid $124 for her five-bedroom apartment. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) paid the remaining balance of $976.
All told, the government forked over roughly $4.25 million in rental assistance last year for residents living at the NY Group properties. That's an average of $540 in monthly rental assistance per apartment - and doesn't include any rent dollars paid out of each tenant's pockets.
"There's a lot of money flying in a lot of different directions for these properties, but none of it is flowing into the buildings the way it's meant to be," Gillam said.
'Tip of the iceberg'
The local case is among the first of many likely to play out on a national scale, said Kelan Craig, who is a housing preservation coordinator at the Coalition of Homeless and Housing in Ohio (COHHIO), a Columbus-based non-profit.
"We think this is just the tip of the iceberg," he said. "There are going to be a lot more portfolios that are expected to be impacted and we'll see even more residents at risk."
Nationally, Ohio ranks No. 3 - just behind New York, and California - for the number of affordable rental units run by private operators that receive millions of dollars in rental subsidy every year from the federal government.
The majority of these properties are backed by HUD-insured mortgages. That means HUD will take ownership of the property if a foreclosure occurs.
"HUD-insured properties require community involvement when there is a foreclosure that brings stakeholders together to ensure the properties are sold to responsible operators and remain affordable," said Bill Faith, executive director at COHHIO.
Potentially at risk in Ohio are more than 330 properties that are backed instead by private mortgages - meaning private lenders like Fannie Mae are responsible for selling off the properties if their owners fall into foreclosure.
"Fannie Mae owns a lot of these mortgages - and when they default they go looking for the highest bidder," said Faith. "Fannie Mae refuses to meet with people who know the conditions of the properties and concerns of the community. There has to be some kind of cooperation to ensure the best interest of the community going forward."
Violations mounting
In Cincinnati, NY Group bought its 19 buildings in 2007 from downtown-based Downtown Property Management Inc.
Soon after, work orders for roof repairs, leaky kitchen faucets and litter control began to pile up, said Ed Cunningham, manager of Cincinnati's property maintenance code enforcement division. Since the July foreclosure filing in Hamilton County Common Pleas Court, Cunningham's department has received calls for collapsed ceilings, electrical fires, and mold.
"We've had a lot of violations on these properties," he said. "So far, we've seen some good faith efforts by the receiver, but I don't know if they're getting the money they need to do all the work."
Fannie Mae says it has worked since July to rectify "several hundred" outstanding code violations. Roughly 28 outstanding working orders from the city remain on the properties. Fannie Mae says it has contracts under way on at least 10 projects to cure code violations.
"While Fannie Mae does not own these properties, we are committed to addressing the health and safety issues," spokeswoman Amy Bonitatibus said. "These properties were grossly mismanaged and as soon as it was brought to our attention, we worked with the court-appointed receiver to allocate several hundred thousand dollars to improve the living conditions for the families who live there."
If major repairs go unmade, property values will decline further, feeding into neighborhood blight, Gillam says.
"These residents and buildings are being abandoned, and it's the communities that get stuck holding the bag," Gillam said. "We get stuck with the blight. We get stuck with the unhappy, desperate families that are left wondering if they're going to be displaced."
Gillam is representing the tenants who are fighting to be heard in the foreclosure case pending against their homes. Currently, the tenants are not considered a party in the foreclosure case.
Too often, she said, tenants in rental communities are forced to sit on the sidelines during foreclosure proceedings that inject uncertainty about the future of the properties and who is responsible for maintaining them.
The process has "unpredictable" results for neighborhoods, said Cunningham. "The mortgagees normally flip foreclosed properties to the highest bidder as quickly as possible and move on," he said.
Gillam said her clients' long-term concern is staying in their homes after new owners are found. If the properties "are sold off willy-nilly - then eventually all of the tenants would be thrown out," she says.
More immediately, tenants would like to see movement on overdue repairs.
"It's overwhelming and frustrating to have to live like this," said Riley, a 37-year-old mother of eight.
In February, she spent nearly a week without electricity in most of her five-bedroom Reading Road apartment.
"The repairs just don't get done, and even some of the people that have been allowed to stay here is concerning," Riley said. "I've gotten jumped over here."
Money sits untapped
National lending giant Fannie Mae is responsible for maintenance and repairs during the foreclosure process. Those repairs are supposed to be funded by through tenant rents and the federal housing subsidy that is now being managed by a court appointed-receiver, Norwood-based The Ackerman Group.
At the end of December, there was about $1.3 million in the receivers fund, according to court documents.
While contracts have been signed for work to be done on some buildings - including a new roof at Bailey's building, Gillam said - major improvements have yet to happen.
"The court has directed them to use the (subsidy) and tenant rents to keep up the buildings, but Fannie Mae doesn't seem interested in that," Gillam said.
In December, Fannie Mae filed a motion asking the court to allow it to remove more than $1 million from the receiver's account. Fannie Mae argued that the large sum is above the limit that can be insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. In the motion, Fannie Mae said it would pledge to make money available as the receiver requests it.
But Gillam said her clients are wary.
"If there's no money in the receiver's fund, how will these repairs get done?" she said.
Reports filed in court by the receiver show that it has hired local property manager Wallick Hendy Development to address maintenance issues. The firm has put in place a small staff to tackle the city work orders, started to replace old boilers and chip away at over due maintenance jobs, according to court filings.
A hearing is set for March 30, in which Judge Beth Myers is scheduled to consider the tenants' request to intervene in the case. Myers is also expected to consider Fannie Mae's request to remove cash from the receiver's fund.
"Until the tenants wanted in the case, no one was complaining about the motion to take out this $1 million," Gillam said.
Pressure for a sale
COHHIO's Craig is working to ensure the properties are sold to investors who will keep them affordable. He said that, so far, he is not getting cooperation from Fannie Mae to facilitate a sale.
"We've identified a number of potential local buyers," Craig says. "We've had pretty limited success in engaging HUD and Fannie Mae with this portfolio though."
Until Fannie Mae officially owns the property - a step that occurs through the official foreclosure sale - "it would be premature to comment on a future sale," Bonitatibus said. " In general, Fannie Mae's goal is to sell multifamily properties to responsible landlord," she said.
Craig argues that Fannie Mae's lack of cooperation flies in the face of the financial regulatory reform bill passed by Congress last year. The law calls on HUD and other federal agencies to ensure that rental properties in foreclosure are sold to responsible landlords committed to keeping the communities affordable.
"This could be the perfect case study, but it doesn't seem that Fannie Mae is interested in being a part of that," Craig said.
The Cincinnati HUD office says it has had regular contact with Fannie Mae since the foreclosure filing. Several buildings in the portfolio are up for regularly scheduled reviews to confirm that they are compliance with HUD regulations, said James Cunningham, a spokesman for the local HUD office.
Before any entity can purchase the NY Group portfolio - or a piece of it - they must be approved by HUD, he said. Even then, the new owners could choose to end contracts with HUD to operate them as affordable housing.
"Yes, there is a risk, but we don't anticipate that happening," Cunningham said.
If the new owners opt out, he said, remaining residents who qualify would be given Section 8 housing vouchers that they could use to offset their rent elsewhere.
Among the local groups interested in getting a piece of the properties is Over-the-Rhine Community Housing, a non-profit manager of more than 400 units of affordable housing.
FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.