Vacation Apartment Rentals: Lucrative and Largely Illegal

Thursday, August 12, 2010
Scott James
The Bay Citizen

Summer in San Francisco brings in gusts of chilly winds and bursts
of tourists. Instead of staying in hotels, a growing number of visitors
opt to live like the locals, renting apartments in the city’s colorful
neighborhoods.

And in hundreds, possibly thousands, of cases, it appears to be illegal for homes to be rented this way.

Obscure city ordinances dating back 30 years are supposed to prevent
apartments from being used as short-term vacation rentals without
pre-approval from the city. But since 2004, only one unit has received
that permission, according to the Department of Building Inspection,
which regulates the practice.

It is a revelation that raises questions about the legality and
consequences of what has become a popular and lucrative piece of the
local hospitality business.

Critics say removing apartments from the housing market and turning
them into vacation rentals has made it harder for people to find
affordable homes. But instead of enforcing the law and stopping the
practice, the city has made money by taxing vacation rentals without
checking first to see if they are legal.

Ted Gullicksen, executive director of the San Francisco Tenants Union, said, “The shorthand we have for it is hotelization.”

Gullicksen said that two-thirds of the city’s 800,000 residents were
renters — there are 180,000 rent-controlled units in the city, the
primary form of housing — and that trying to preserve them is “a
constant struggle.” He estimated that during some recent years as many
as 1,000 rental units were lost, converted into private homes, like
condominiums, or corporate leases and vacation rentals.

In 1981 — when there was concern about single-room occupancy housing
for the poor being leased to visitors — the city adopted an ordinance
to prohibit renting an apartment for fewer than 30 days unless it had
been converted for tourist use, a lengthy process that costs about
$41,000 per unit.

But while only one conversion has been officially approved in recent years, the vacation-rental business has boomed.

One popular Web site, Vacation Rentals By Owner, showed 521 listings
in San Francisco recently, with some advertisements featuring multiple
properties. Craigslist, Come2SF and other services also facilitate
vacation rentals. There is no official tally of how many apartments are
used for tourists, but over the course of years the number could be in
the thousands.

A recent surge in popularity of vacation rentals has been fueled, in
part, by the recession, said Christine Karpinski of Vacation Rentals By
Owner. “We’ve seen a significant increase in properties being added
every day,” Karpinski said, noting that the price per night tends to be
less than half what a hotel room costs.

Karpinski, whose company requires users to sign an agreement
pledging to obey local ordinances, said vacation rentals tended to
provide higher revenues for property owners, an average of $33,000 per
year, per unit, than residential rentals. Studios in San Francisco
typically lease for $14,400 a year. The increase in revenues appeals to
landlords, but the money has also enriched city coffers because
vacation rentals, unlike permanent tenancies, are subject to a 14
percent hotel tax.

David Augustine, spokesman for the City Treasurer’s Office, said the
department had been collecting the tax on vacation rentals. There was
no accounting available to show how much revenue came from the rentals,
Augustine said, but the hotel tax is one of the most lucrative for the
city: $150 million estimated for this fiscal year.

The Treasurer’s Office deploys investigators to find vacation
rentals and make the owner pay the tax. But the office does not share
its list of vacation rentals with the Department of Building Inspection
to see if the properties have permission to operate as rentals.

Augustine said there might be some confidentiality issues if tax
information was shared with inspectors. Asked if future cooperation was
possible, he said the office would be “happy to have that conversation.”

But any new enforcement effort could be undermined by the way the
ordinance on rentals was written. It is unclear if it applies to
buildings of all sizes or whether owners can reside part-time and rent
to tourists occasionally.

David Chiu, an outspoken critic of vacation rentals and president of
the city’s Board of Supervisors, said he would “see if there are ways
to strengthen the law.” He added, “We have an extreme scarcity of
housing for our residents.”

An increase in available housing could not come fast enough for
residents like Aarthi Ananthanarayanan. Visiting an available,
minuscule $1,195 per month studio in the Mission district — with its
view of a wall and a toilet that flushed itself every two minutes —
Ananthanarayanan said she was on her second hunt in a year to find a
decent home.

She wants her own space after paying $875 a month to share an
apartment with no heat in Noe Valley, where she had had to prevail over
dozens of other applicants to get the room.

“I don’t think this place is quite right,” she said, smiling good-naturedly, as the toilet flushed itself again.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

 

Help build power for renters' rights: