Vanishing Treasure: The Rent-Regulated Apartment

Monday, May 24, 2010
CHRISTINE HAUGHNEY
The New York Times

Rent-controlled and rent-stabilized apartments carry mythic
significance to New Yorkers starved for space. These are the
high-ceiling homes featured in Woody Allen movies, the places secured by celebrities like Carly Simon, Cyndi Lauper and Ed Koch.

They are the reason that Monica on “Friends” was able to afford her apartment on a chef’s salary.

Of course, Monica is a fictional character, but awe-inspiring,
teeth-clenching deals still do exist. An informal survey of some major
landlords and real estate agencies turned up an Upper East Side woman
paying $156.20 for two conjoined studios, a Lower East Side man paying
$60 a month for a walk-up, and octogenarians and nonagenarians
sprinkled through Little Italy paying $58 to $102 a month.

Most of these tenants with time-warped rents declined to be
interviewed, because of the hate mail they believed they would receive.
But one such tenant did agree to go on the record, and he wants his
fellow New Yorkers to know that he has not been able to keep his cheap
apartment without a long fight.

He is John Burke, a 65-year-old paying $288 a month for a studio at 218
East 84th Street. As the last rent-stabilized dweller in a five-story
walk-up, Mr. Burke is living in a construction site where the latest
landlord is renovating all the other studios and charging $1,850 to
$1,975 a month. Mr. Burke says he has spent $13,500 to repair his
dilapidated apartment and $11,000 on legal fees taking his landlords to
court over the conditions.

He is waiting for his current landlord to find him a temporary
apartment, make repairs and let him return home. But there are no
guarantees when or if that might happen.

As Mr. Burke carefully walked through the sweltering apartment, stacked
to the ceiling with furniture he was waiting to move, he inhaled the
unsettling scent of mold, ignored the head-splitting sawing and
hammering from floors above him, and poked his dark-wood cane at
rotting floorboards his landlord had not repaired.

“It’s been hell,” Mr. Burke said while walking among glass shards that
construction had left strewn about the backyard. “Now you see, it’s no
bargain.”

As with many other things that money and gentrification have scrubbed
from the city, the number of these apartments is shrinking. The roster
of rent-controlled apartments, the ones with the most restrictions on
rent, has shrunk to 40,000, according to the State Division of Housing and Community Renewal.
When these units are emptied, they often become rent stabilized, and
after a certain point the apartments can be liberated to the free
market. According to the most recent figures available, the number of
rent-stabilized units fell to 848,000 in 2008 from 900,000 in 2003. And
outside of prime neighborhoods, the restricted rents are not such a great bargain, in many cases barely cheaper than what the apartments could fetch on the open market.

The deteriorating low-priced apartments still exist partly because
landlords have little financial incentive to make renovations or apply
for rent increases. Stabilized rents increase by order of the local
Rent Guidelines Board, typically around 3 percent a year, while
controlled rents can go up only if the landlord files an application
for an increase with the state, a laborious process. And the state will
not allow a rent increase if an apartment has major housing code
violations.

Sherwin Belkin, a Manhattan
lawyer who represents owners and developers, said landlords often say
it is not worth the time to apply for increases that could translate
into just a few dollars more a month.

While it is less true today, rent-regulated apartments have provided
some New Yorkers with very comfortable lives. Mr. Burke, who grew up in
Ireland on a farm outside Galway, moved to New York in 1964 to be close
to his brother upstate and his 100 relatives in Massachusetts. He
worked in restaurants and bars and collected decades of tales of
celebrity sightings and romances. He moved into his current apartment
in 1977, when the rent was $65, and filled his closets with handsome
clothes.

As new owners bought his building and pressed tenants to leave, Mr.
Burke held his ground. He was careful to pay his rent by check or money
order, not cash, to have a paper trail. But an accident in the
Catskills in 1995 left Mr. Burke unable to work and with little spare
money. He currently lives on an $1,100 monthly disability check. He
finds solace reading historical romance novels about lords and earls by
authors like Julia London.

Mr. Burke has reached a stalemate with his latest landlord, the Shalom
family, which bought the building last year for $3.3 million. He is
working with State Senator Liz Krueger, the nonprofit Eviction Intervention Services and the tenant rights group Shalom Tenants Alliance,
which is fighting the landlord over its management of more than 100
buildings. Calls and e-mail messages to the Shalom family at their firm
Sky Management, to the past landlord and to brokers renting out
apartments were not returned.

Catie Marshall, a spokeswoman for the city’s Department of Housing Preservation and Development,
said the agency was “aware of the conditions of his apartment” and
wanted it “to be brought up to all of the standards of the housing
code.” The building currently has 190 violations, including 76 in that
specific unit. For example, the department has asked the landlord to
repair the broken kitchen sink and bathroom floor tiles. The Department
of Buildings is also monitoring the building and has issued 18 notices
of environmental control board violations.

Still, Mr. Burke’s eyes twinkled when he was asked whether there was any benefit to the battle for his bargain apartment.

“I have been fighting for other tenants and myself,” he said. “We can leave a road map showing people how to win.”

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: