Owners of illegal rental units and garage conversions in Ventura could legalize the dwellings at a reduced cost and without risk of civil penalties if they come forward during a limited period, under a proposed amnesty program the City Council will consider Monday.
The amnesty program for second units is one of nearly a dozen proposals by city officials to ensure safe housing and better manage often-controversial code enforcement challenges.
The proposals before the council Monday night would touch virtually every tenant and landlord citywide.
City officials know of at least 60 illegal dwellings and suspect hundreds more exist that, without proper inspection, could have tenants living at potential risk. Two years ago, a fire caused by an overloaded electrical outlet in an illegal addition sent one person to the hospital, and there have been other close calls, enforcement officials said.
The proposals culminate a nearly two-year effort that includes input from a council-created group of citizens and professionals who drafted recommendations.
Ventura is dotted with older, established neighborhoods (more than 70 percent of its housing stock is older than 30 years), and code enforcement often generates heated citizen reaction. Some residents argue enforcement policies invade their private lives, while others complain the city doesn't do enough to root out illegal dwellings and poorly maintained properties that can negatively affect entire neighborhoods.
The city-commissioned Safe Housing Collaborative citizens group conducted surveys and collected input from hundreds of people. Many homeowners didn't know or chose to ignore city housing rules, didn't trust code enforcement and avoided doing the right thing because the city permits cost too much or they feared a city inspection would uncover numerous and costly violations, the group found.
While city officials incorporated much of the group's input into their proposals, some collaborative members said the council should adopt its recommendations because they best represent the public's views.
"We think our report stands on its own," Vice Chairman Ken Luper said.
One of the panel's suggestions not supported by Jeff Lambert, Ventura's community development director, is creating a citizens review board to ensure due process. Lambert said a city Local Appeals Board serves this role.
The City Council can decide how many of the group's suggestions to incorporate or ignore. The collaborative's report can be found online at http:www.grandfatherventura.com.
The city staff proposals include:
- A "2nd Unit Amnesty Permit" to allow property owners to legalize an undocumented rental at a reduced cost and without risk of civil penalties as long as the owner comes clean by the end of this year. After that, a discovered illegal unit would be treated as a brand-new unit that would have to pay $1,500 in permit fees and $10,300 plus a water deposit to connect to the city's water and sewage systems.
- A notarized "Local Resale Inspection Report" to accompany all real estate sales after July 1. The standardized report documenting parcel numbers, a detailed list of all on-site structures and proof of a private inspection, would be filed with the city by the seller before the close of escrow, and carry a $38 fee. Both the seller and buyer would have to sign. Failure to do so could result in a city citation.
- Creation of a citywide database of all rentals of four units or smaller, and a "Move In Move Out" form that landlords and tenants would have to sign and submit to the city before occupancy. The form, modeled after one used by the California Apartment Association, would help ensure no unit is rented in a substandard condition and protect landlords from tenants who abuse their properties and then claim the unit had been that way. The form would be required starting Jan. 1 and there would be a $19 city processing fee. There are an estimated 2,000 four-plex or smaller rentals citywide, the proposal says.
n Rebranding of the city code enforcement division to "Neighborhood Preservation," with emphasis on "assisting" residents as well as enhanced education outreach. Enforcement officers would no longer make cold calls to investigate reported violations, instead sending a request-of-inspection letter, and they would record all interactions.
- A 12-month pilot program to allow licensed contractors to become deputized by the city to certify water heater and furnace replacements and roofing projects. Residents who hire the contractors would pay a reduced replacement permit fee and would not have to file documentation with the city because the deputized contractor would do it for them. To qualify, contractors would have to attend training, pass a competency exam and sign papers promising to uphold city law.
- Creation of a volunteer program modeled after the Police Department's Volunteer In Police effort, where volunteers would receive training and use of a city vehicle to help document and enforce lower-priority violations.
Two years ago, the City Council voted to change from a decades-old, complaint-based form of code enforcement to a "proactive" house-to-house inspection program to better identify poorly maintained properties and illegal units and bring them into compliance. The shift generated mixed reviews, anxiety and criticism.
Neighbors affected by trash-strewn lots favored the crackdown, while others felt it was heavy-handed and poorly timed due to the recession. Some landowners complained they didn't know their units were unauthorized and they couldn't afford the thousands of dollars needed to improve and legalize their rentals, some of which were being used to house family members.
Tenant advocates argued unauthorized units deemed safe should be "grandfathered" and allowed to stay, because they provide affordable housing for low-wage earners and seniors on fixed incomes.
Critics argued city code enforcement staff couldn't be impartial, so the council appointed the 13-person Safe Housing Collaborative to make recommendations.
The council meets at 6 p.m. Monday at City Hall, 501 Poli St.
FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.