Visalia mobile-home residents and owners of mobile-home parks remain at odds even as a new space-rent ordinance is being drafted and scheduled for discussion Tuesday at a Visalia City Council work session.
The old ordinance, which was unevenly followed by park owners, was first put into place in 1996 and expires in May. Without another so-called "master lease" program, park owners will be free to charge "what the market will bear," which will have a net effect of pushing elderly residents into homelessness, advocates say.
"It amounts to economic eviction," said Jim Burr, a longtime resident of the Westlake Village mobile-home park and noted state-level expert in mobile-home issues.
Mobile-home residents claim that owners of Visalia's 10 mobile-home residential parks routinely gouge new residents while relentlessly pushing up rents on helpless long-term residents on fixed incomes who have no other cost-effective housing option, Burr said.
Since 2003, space-rent increases at Visalia's parks have been as high as 44 percent — more than double the federal cost-of-living increase of 16 percent over the same time range — according to a study completed by Kenneth Baar and commissioned by the city last year.
Another study done by a consultant handpicked by Visalia's park owners, John Neet, states that Visalia's 2003-08 space-rent increases have been a collective 24 percent during that period, still above the national cost-of-living rate.
"It's the park owners who supply the rent rolls and other data [for both studies]," Burr said. "It can be shown that the information they supply is simply wrong — misleading at best."
Still, Visalia over its history as a city has at least attempted to protect mobile-home residents from rent-gouging, short of outright rent control, which neither side really wants to see.
In fact, a citizens' committee composed of three park owners, three representatives of Visalia park residents and three at-large citizens who have no connection with mobile-home living have been at work trying to craft terms both sides can live with.So far, those efforts have been disappointing, Burr said.
"Park owners have been recalcitrant," Burr said. "At the very outset [early 2009] they set an ultimatum and have not budged."
The "ultimatum" calls for a master-lease agreement that calls for annual space-rent increases of between 3.5 and 7 percent. Residents have agreed to a 1.5 to 5 percent range. However, park owners insist that any time a resident sells his or her mobile home and moves out of a park, no limit will be placed on the rent increase for any newcomer. Residents want a 15-percent cap on so-called "vacancy controls."
Burr pays $550 per month space rent at Westlake Village, considered to be one of the more affluent mobile-home parks in the city.
"But that could easily go up $150 or more to $700-plus to anyone who would want to buy my home," Burr said. "That kind of increase not only wipes out any equity I might have [in he mobile home itself], but makes my home practically unsellable."
The council has placed a March 1 deadline to come up with a new mobile-home lease ordinance
FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.