Local animal rights activists may soon gain traction in banning cat
declawing and animal devocalization as the California State Senate
reviews a new bill this month that would prohibit landlords from
requiring their tenants to declaw or devocalize their animals or from
preferring the application of a tenant with a declawed animal.
Assembly
Bill 2743, authored by Assemblymember Pedro Nava (D-Ventura, Santa
Barbara), introduces a civil fine of as much as $2,500 for any instance
of declawing or devocalization that occurs because of a landlord-tenant
agreement.
“We feel, since tenancy is a transient state, where
people are moving from apartment to apartment or house to house, they
shouldn’t be doing something so permanent to their animals,” said Dr.
Jennifer Conrad, veterinarian and founder of the Paw Project, a
nonprofit anti-declawing organization sponsoring the bill.
Devocalization,
or debarking, involves removing tissue from an animal’s vocal cords in
order to lower the volume of the sound it can make and is currently
banned in Massachusetts and New Jersey.
Though controversial,
declawing is seen to be inhumane by many veterinarians and animal
rights activists, because it removes not only the cat’s claws, but also
the last digit of each of its toes. It is illegal in many European
countries, and was outlawed recently in eight California cities,
including Los Angeles and San Francisco.
But according to Nava,
despite bans in those cities, it is still common to see declawing or
devocalization as a condition of tenancy in rental advertisements.
“The
thing that was particularly troubling,” Nava said, “was if you had a
landlord that required that procedure, the tenant was put in a real
dilemma.”
Under the bill, a tenant whose landlord disobeyed the
law could go to a nonprofit organization such as the Humane Society for
assistance in bringing a suit.
Officials at the Humane Society
and the Ventura County Animal Regulation Department said declawed cats
are not common at animal shelters in the area, but they come in more
regularly than debarked dogs.
Some say declawing cats leads to
destructive behavioral changes, as well as occasionally causing medical
complications. Because claws are a cat’s major method of self-defense,
some argue that declawed cats are more likely to bite if they feel
threatened. Some cats also stop using their litterboxes because it is
painful for them to dig in the sand.
“I deterred a woman from
actually getting her cat declawed just by pulling out the pictures [of
declawing],” said Tami Brown, veterinary technician at the Humane
Society in Ojai. In her experience, declawed cats who have come into
the shelter have not wanted to use the litterbox and have had trouble
walking.
Many veterinarians, Conrad said, package declawing
with spaying or neutering, so owners believe they are doing the right
thing for the kitten. “They talk about declawing as if it’s some fancy
manicure,” she said. “It’s not. It’s removing the last bone. A more
accurate term would be ‘deknuckling.’ ”
The California
Veterinary Medical Association opposes the bill, according to Dr. Mark
Nunez, the association’s president, because although it doesn’t
necessarily approve of the procedures, it doesn’t want lawmakers making
medical decisions for veterinarians and pet owners.
The
association disagrees with the idea that cats experience behavioral
changes after declawing and does not want to see language to that
effect written into law. Nunez said that although he rarely declaws
cats, he has never seen complications arise from the surgery. “Even in
the studies that state there is an increasing risk of biting, the
numbers are always in the minority,” he said.
However, the
California Apartment Association supports the bill, as it encourages
landlords to make pet owners responsible for their pets’ behavior.
“We
just don’t think declawing or devocalizing animals is right,” said Eric
Wiegers, vice president of communication for the California Apartment
Association, which represents more than 17,000 members and their
employees in the state.
There are a few alternatives to declawing,
such as using a scratching post, trimming the nails or using Soft Paws,
vinyl caps that cover a cat’s claws and prevent them from scratching.
For
many, scratching activities are behavioral problems that can be fixed
with training. “If you have a kid that bites his nails, you don’t chop
off his fingers,” Conrad said.
For those who want to help
animals in need, the band Champagne Sunday will be playing a benefit
show for Fun-E-Bone Pet Rescue at the Christian Church of Thousand Oaks
this Friday, July 2, from 5 to 10 p.m. Tickets are $10 for adults and
$5 for students.
Opposed to AB 2743? You can send letters to
state legislators and the governor asking them to vote against the bill
by visiting the California Veterinary Medical Assocation’s website at www.cvma.net.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.