Walter Lembi, who presided over San Francisco's largest residential real estate empire before much of it fell away, died Tuesday of cancer.
Having battled cancer of the esophagus for the past year, Mr. Lembi,
63, succumbed peacefully, with his family around him, at UCSF Medical
Center, where he had spent the past four months in intensive care.
"Walter will remain one of the iconic figures in the apartment
market in San Francisco," said Craig Lipton, owner of Maven
Investments, a real estate investment and development firm in San
Francisco, who knew Mr. Lembi for many years.
Mr. Lembi leaves behind a real estate conglomerate, which, at its
zenith in 2008, owned more than 300 apartment buildings in San
Francisco, but is currently besieged by bankruptcies, foreclosures and
receiverships.
The company's business practices have also been criticized,
especially by tenants groups. Several lawsuits have been filed,
including one by City Attorney Dennis Herrera, alleging harassment,
illegal evictions and rent raises, lack of repairs and failure to repay
security deposits.
"There was nothing particularly notorious until they went on a
buying spree in the middle of the decade. Then they developed a
well-defined strategy of harassing rent-controlled tenants out of their
buildings in order to raise the rents to market levels," said Ted
Gullicksen, director of the San Francisco Tenants Union. "It was
successful for a while, then there was pushback, the financial
collapse, and the Lembis started losing buildings."
Mr. Lembi rarely spoke to the press or responded to the criticisms
about the company's business practices, but in an August 2008 interview
for the San Francisco Apartment Association's monthly magazine, he said, "We do not bully tenants, ever."
The only son of family patriarch Frank Lembi, Walter Lembi was born in San Francisco in 1947 and graduated from Santa Clara University
in business and marketing and was a pitcher for the university baseball
team. His real estate career, he said, began in 1972 when he went to
work as a salesman for Skyline Realty,
which Frank Lembi founded in 1946 and became the cornerstone of the
family-owned empire, commonly referred to as CitiApartments.
"The first building I sold in 1972 was three flats on Church and
18th streets for $30,000," Walter Lembi told the magazine. "Now think
about that. Those same flats are worth $2.1 million today."
In the 1980s,
father and son owned Continental Savings of America, an S&L that
specialized in real estate loans. With "liabilities exceeding its
assets, and suffering losses that depleted all of its capital," it was
taken over by the Resolution Trust Corp. and its reported $370 million
in assets was handed off to Los Angeles' California Federal Bank in 1995.
Returning to the family real estate fold in 1998, Mr. Lembi oversaw
more than $1 billion worth of investments in San Francisco apartment
buildings between 2003 and 2008. But with the market collapse, it
became increasingly difficult to meet the payments on large and complex
loans, many of which Mr. Lembi had put together.
Five months later, the Swiss bank UBS took back 51 buildings on which the Lembi Group owed up to $400 million.
More foreclosures and receiverships culminated last month with four
Lembi subsidiaries filing for bankruptcy and 29 more buildings going
into receivership. The group is estimated to have lost one-half of its
properties since the 2008 high point.
"His intoxication with the endless streams of capital provided to
him from various Wall Street banks clearly led to the downfall of the
family business," said Lipton. "But he also oversaw the largest and
most ambitious renovation plan of downtown and Tenderloin apartment
buildings that the city has ever seen.
"He spent tens of millions of dollars on an aging and sometimes
blighted housing stock, significantly elevating the tax base for
hundreds of properties and restoring downtown properties that had often
been neglected for decades.
"This is the legacy of Walter Lembi that is generally overlooked."
A large man physically, Mr. Lembi was described by friends and
business associates as "a big guy and a big-hearted guy," "larger than
life," and "very easy to be around." He also lived large, which got him
into trouble in Las Vegas last year when the Clark County district
attorney's office issued a warrant for Mr. Lembi for $298,500 worth of
markers owed to Caesars Palace.
The case was settled when Mr. Lembi agreed to pay off the amount in full, plus fees.
With Mr. Lembi's passing, management of the business will likely be
more in the hands of David Reynal, Mr. Lembi's cousin and the nephew of
Frank Lembi, who, at age 92, is still involved in the business.
Walter Lembi leaves behind an ex-wife, two sons, Taylor and Damon;
two daughters, Samantha and Chelsea; and three sisters, Francine Lembi,
Lisa Sayed and Yvonne Lembi-Detert. Funeral arrangements have not been
announced.
"He was the best father, brother and son you could have," said
Lembi-Detert. "He always fought hard for the business, loved San
Francisco and left his heart here."