Is WeHo encouraging condo conversions?

Monday, July 4, 2011
WeHo News staff, West Hollywood, California
WeHo News

A staff proposal being presented to the West Hollywood Planning Commission this Thursday would make it easier for landlords owning buildings on the National Register of Historic Places to evict renters and replace tenants with homeowners.

El Mirador, already being vacated, is in line to go condo if city planning staff wins the day. Photo by WeHo News.

Citing El Mirador, the Jerome Nash-owned rental Building at 1302 North Sweetzer Ave. (at Fountain) with 32 units, as one of the buildings that would qualify, the proposal provides landlords owning Historic Buildings with 21 or more units who wish to leave the rental business a leg up on the process.

The proposal would

1. Permit fee waivers;

2. Transfer of development rights;

3. Change of use or adaptive reuse;

4. Mills Act Agreements;

5. Reduction in the development standards of this Zoning Ordinance;

6. The permitting of uses not allowed in the zone, but which are permitted in other zones;

  7. Affordable housing requirement (Chapter 19.22) waiver for the conversion of rental units into common interest developments for buildings with 21 or more units and eligible for the National Register as identified in the Historic Resources Inventory or listed on the National Register; and

8. Development fee (Chapter 19.64, Table 4-3) waiver for the conversion of rental units into common interest developments for buildings with 21 or more units and eligible for the National Register as identified in the Historic Resources Inventory or listed on the National Register.

Staff reports that the problem they wish to address is the deferred maintenance that has some of these buildings falling apart.

This photo of the Palacio dates to 1934.

Apparently the city’s rent stabilization law is written too tightly to allow landlords to recoup maintenance expenses through the Net Operating Income (NOI) procedure from tenants, leaving the landlords nowhere to turn but to evict the tenants and sell the units as condos.

In a hearing before the Historic Preservation Commission last week, the proposal received a welcome hearing – in fact, the commission asked that the proposal be extended to smaller buildings.

That commission would like to see buildings as small as 11 units included in the condo conversion plan.

This law stems from years’ long struggle with the problem of crumbling apartments in need of expensive, deferred maintenance.

WeHo News reported on the Palacio, the courtyard apartment building gracing Fountain Ave. in 2006, and how landlords such as Richard Weintraub, who owns the Palacio, have not abided by Mills Act, which provides special tax incentives for maintenance of historic buildings.

The buildings targeted for special treatment are:

1. 1285-1289 N. Crescent Heights Boulevard (La Fontaine), 24 units;

2. 1334-1336 N. Harper Avenue (Casa Granada), 21 units; and

3. 1302-1310 N. Sweetzer Avenue (El Mirador), 32 units  

The last building on the list, insiders say, is the real reason for the ordinance’s coming forward.

Beginning in 2006 Jerome Nash, a major landlord, began trying to fix the windows in his building so that water damage from the leaky panes, sashes and frames could be solved.

The decades-old windows need to be replaced with water-tight windows to help protect what Mr. Nash described as the building's "crumbling plaster; it's falling apart from water damage and the city won't let me prevent that."

The windows, which “are literally falling off the building," he said, referring to a 2006 incident in which one of the Sweetzer-side window panes fell four floors to the street, and pose a safety hazard to passerbys.

Code compliance cited Mr. Nash for the windows’ poor maintenance and gave the tenants a rent reduction until the window was replaced.

The window is still nailed shut.

The City's Historic Preservation Commission denied a request from Mr. Nash to replace the windows on the local cultural landmark with new windows as not in conformance with the historic nature of the building.

After a five year battle to replace the windows, with WeHo City Code Compliance issuing citations, Rent Stabilization issuing rent reductions and Planning preventing him from fixing anything, Mr. Nash tired of the process and evicted all the tenants and plans to leave the building vacant for five years.

Mr. Nash informed WeHo News that the city presented several alternative use proposals after he invoked the Ellis Act and evicted the tenants, some of whom had lived there for 20, 30 and forty years.

One city-offered proposal was to convert the building to a hotel.

Another was to take the building condo, but the city asked for nearly $1 million in affordable housing in lieu fees from Mr. Nash for the privilege.

His anger at the city – and John Heilman’s office in particular - is such that he told WeHo News repeatedly in interviews, “I will NEVER take the building condo; I wish John Heilman had lost the election and I will do anything I can to see him defeated in the next election.”

Mr. Nash claims he was asked by the city attorney, Mike Jenkins, to avoid discussion of the situation until after the March election, so as not to cause Mr. Heilman any difficulties in his re-election bid.

The lack of window maintenance, Mr. Nash contends, was never at issue at El Mirador; he bought full ownership from a partner in 2006 “because [the partner] wouldn’t spend money on maintenance,” he said.

He showed WeHo News estimates amounting to $1.25 million for the windows’ replacement, a figure he was eager to spend if the city would allow it.

Since Ellising the building, the city’s deputy city manager, Anne MaIntosh, stepped in and unilaterally overruled the Historic Preservation Commission’s decision to prevent the new windows from going in.

One commissioner, who saw the same window and refused to allow it to go on El Mirador because it contained an aluminum sash, now praises the windows as a perfect solution.

In April, when WeHo News toured the building with him, Mr. Nash was obtaining an updated estimate from the contractor for those same windows he tried to install five years earlier.

In the days following the Ellising of El Mirador, WeHo city council member John Duran held out hope that "cooler heads will prevail at some point, because a dispute over historic preservation shouldn't result in the eviction of long-term tenants."

Those cooler heads came up with a plan that advocates evicting tenants to “save” historic buildings.

FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together.  This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: