More than
400 East Palo Alto tenants living in Page Mill Properties' former
buildings recently got good news in the mail from Wells Fargo Bank.
The
bank, which took over Page Mill's 1,800 East Palo Alto rental units in
March after the company failed to make a $50 million balloon payment and
defaulted on a loan, decided to reduce rents at 437 apartments
effective May 1, spokeswoman Elise Wilkinson said Tuesday.
"We
have recently reviewed the rents for all tenants at Woodland Park
(apartments), and, based on that review, have reduced certain rents to
bring those rents within what we understand to be the current allowable
(rent stabilization ordinance) guidelines," Wilkinson said in an e-mail.
"The rents on 437 units were reduced. No rents were increased."
The
reductions represent a significant break from the sometimes hefty
increases tenants at the buildings received for about two years after
Page Mill began buying units in 2006.
The issue became emotional
and legally fraught after residents began showing up at city council
meetings in late 2007, reporting increases as large as 50 percent. East
Palo Alto attempted to stop the hikes in court and through changes to
its rent control law's rules and regulations section but was
unsuccessful, as Page Mill began launching numerous lawsuits in San
Mateo County Superior Court.
Hundreds of tenants left the
buildings because they couldn't afford the new rents or received
eviction notices, community groups say.
The
city has met multiple times this year with court-appointed receiver
Dave Wald and bank representatives in an attempt to settle about eight
active lawsuits remaining between Page Mill and East Palo Alto, Council
Member Ruben Abrica said Wednesday.
Council members were expected
to sign a settlement agreement during a closed session Tuesday night but
decided they needed to iron out a few kinks in the document, Abrica
said.
"We did have something in writing, but it was mostly drafted
by their attorney," Abrica said. "When we looked at it, we felt there
were a couple of things missing."
The sides haven't decided yet
whether to publicly disclose the settlement terms, he said.
Abrica
added that the rent rollbacks are part of the tentative agreement,
although he believes Wells Fargo already intended to make some
reductions. Some of the remaining litigation centered on differences of
opinion about calculating the formula for rent increases.
Tenant
Matt Martin said he was thrilled to receive an April 30 letter from
property manager Investors' Property Services stating that his rent
would be reduced from $1,350 to $1,151 on May 1.
Martin, 34, has
lived in an apartment complex on East O'Keefe Street for 12 years but
moved into his current unit five years ago.
Shortly after the
birth of his first child, Martin said Page Mill raised his rent by about
$350 over a three-month period. Martin and his wife began cutting back
on cell phone and car usage, but some of his neighbors fell into
financial straits with the increases, he said.
"I'm really blessed
— I've got a job, and I get health benefits," Martin said. "One of our
neighbors in particular, they don't have enough money to buy groceries
at the end of the month."
Page Mill recently vacated its Cowper
Street offices in Palo Alto and moved to a building in Menlo Park,
spokesman Sam Singer said last month. Singer described the move as
temporary and said the company will likely return to Palo Alto.
Singer
couldn't reach Page Mill officials for comment Wednesday afternoon.
Abrica
said he expects the settlement agreement to come before the council at
its next meeting on May 18. Should council members approve it, a San
Mateo County Superior Court judge will still need to sign off, he said.
Meanwhile,
the Stanford Community Law Clinic is still negotiating a separate
settlement with Wells Fargo for its 136 clients living at the former
Page Mill buildings.
Supervising attorney Jessica Steinberg said
Wednesday that many of her clients have received rent reductions, though
she isn't sure whether all were included.
"We are hoping their
rents will be reduced, that they might receive some form of a rebate and
that any unlawful fees imposed will be eliminated," Steinberg said. "We
are negotiating all those issues."
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.