When Your Landlord Fights a Foreclosure Sale

Thursday, August 26, 2010
Jennifer Saranow Schultz
The New York Times


Back in the October Bucks post “What to Do When Your Landlord Is Going Through Foreclosure,”
I described how I came home to find a notice on our building’s front
door, and another in our mailbox, saying the foreclosure process had
begun on the property. So I did some research on what rights tenants
have in such situations.

At the time, I thought my landlords had worked out a repayment
agreement with their bank and all would be O.K. I also didn’t come
across any more notices on the building since. You can imagine my
surprise then, last month, when people started ringing the buzzer asking
to see the apartment, saying the building was up for a trustee sale
that day. (No, I didn’t let any of them in).

Soon after, we received a notice saying the building had been sold to
the highest bidder and now was under new ownership. All rent and
questions about ownership were to be directed to the new owner. They
also sent us a copy of the deed verifying new ownership. Meanwhile, our
old landlords said the bank had sold the property in error, without
notifying them, and they were planning to file a lawsuit.

As foreclosures spread nationwide so too do the instances of
contentious cases, likely leaving many tenants in such situations
wondering who to pay the rent to, let alone who to trust. To find out
what tenants should do when their old landlord fights a foreclosure
sale, I consulted a couple experts.

As a tenant, the experts agreed that in such situations, your
responsibility is not to determine who is in the right but rather to
make sure you don’t end up getting double-billed for the rent. “It’s
going to be very difficult for a tenant to ascertain who is really in
the right here,” said Jeremy Rosen, policy director at the National Law Center on Homelessness & Poverty. “What tenants really need to focus on is making sure that you’re only going to have to pay rent to one person once.”

The experts I talked with agreed that if the new owner has the deed
(with the official stamp) showing ownership has been transferred, rent
should go to the new owner after you’ve confirmed you can stay and
gotten a copy of a new lease from the new owner.

Still, the experts said, be sure to document the payments – who they
went to, for how much and when – to the extent possible. Documentation
could include keeping receipts for and paying with certified checks or
money orders; sending checks via certified mail and keeping receipts for
the mailings; keeping copies of canceled checks and asking for receipts
from the new owner for rent payments.

“If the old owners are found to be the winners in court and ownership
is restored, it is really critical for people to have this record that
they were paying rent so the old owners can’t come back and say ‘now you
owe us rent’ for months when you paid it,” Mr. Rosen said.

Still, when you are paying the rent to the new owner based on a
trustee deed of a foreclosure sale as evidence, “it’s hard to imagine
that you are going to have to pay the rent twice,” said Stephen R.
Elias, an attorney in California and author of Nolo’s the Foreclosure Survival Guide. That’s because, he said, it’s very hard for old owners to overturn such sales once they go through.

If, however, the new owners don’t have sufficient official paperwork
or you don’t feel confident about who really owns the building, then
setting up an escrow or an escrowlike account to store rent may be a
good idea, the experts said, if such an account is allowed under the
landlord-tenant laws where you live.

But since it’s up to the new owners whether they are going to kick
you out or not, you may want to think carefully about your actions if
you want to stay in your place. If you are difficult to deal with or
don’t pay the rent, “they’ll move you out at the first opportunity,” Mr.
Elias said.

Regardless of what you chose to do, the experts also said it’s a good
idea to consult with your local housing rights office and if possible, a
local real estate lawyer.

Have you been a tenant or landlord in such a situation? If so, what did you do?

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: