Where landlords, developers, and cars are king

Wednesday, March 3, 2010
San Francisco Bay Guardian

EDITORIAL Are cars more important than people? Is it okay to
evict a tenant just to make space for a garage? Should new garages be
designed to preserve on-street parking too? Seems like a no-brainer to
us. But legislation by Sup. David Chiu that would put some limits on
the expansion of garages — an increasing problem in Chinatown and North
Beach — has infuriated some real estate interests, and it's possible
that this eminently reasonable bill might fail.

It's a sad statement on San Francisco politics, and the implications go way beyond this one planning measure.

The problem has its roots in the Ellis Act, the state law
that allows landlords to clear all the tenants out of a building, then
sell it to wealthier people who want to buy their units as tenants in
common (TICs). The Ellis Act has been responsible for thousands of San
Franciscans losing their homes — and a new twist has been developing in
Chiu's district.

In the crowded Chinatown-North Beach area, parking is at a
premium and people who are buying TICs want a place to put their cars.
So landlords and speculators are throwing out tenants not just for new
owners, but to make room for garages.

Chiu's law — which would apply only in parts of District 3 —
would deny building owners a permit to construct a new garage if a
tenant was evicted under the Ellis Act in the past 10 years. And it
would require a conditional use authorization from the City Planning
Department for any new garage construction.

Chiu also wants new rules for curb cuts — the openings in
sidewalks that allow cars to drive into garages. The cuts would have to
be as small as possible and designed to preserve on-street parking.

On a larger level, the bill would make it easier to construct
new housing without parking — a significant change in how San Francisco
has handled off-street parking for many years. Instead of mandating
garages in new apartment buildings, Chiu wants to discourage them. He's
saying, in essence, that space for people is more important than space
for cars.

That's a logical step in a city that is trying to enforce a
transit-first policy. It's a small piece of a larger political battle
to transform a city planning system that for too long has been driven
by the needs of the private automobile. It should have passed
unanimously and Mayor Newsom should sign it into law.

In fact, the bill passed on first reading Feb. 9, with only
Sups. Sean Elsbernd and Carmen Chu voting against it. But Sup. Bevan
Dufty now says he has concerns about the measure, and Chiu has agreed
to postpone the final vote until March 9.

Dufty's a key vote, because it's likely at this point that
the mayor will veto the measure. And with Elsbernd and Chu opposed and
Michela Alioto-Pier still out with health problems, supporters can't
override a veto without Dufty.

We couldn't reach Dufty, but supporters of the bill say he
wants the measure watered down to eliminate the conditional use
requirement — which would force city planners to check and make sure
the builder or landlord was following the rules — and replace it with a
discretionary review requirement, which would allow the garage
construction unless someone objected. That puts the burden on the
tenants (who in many cases are low income people whose primary language
isn't English) to protect themselves. And it would undermine much of
the power of the bill.

It's insane for Dufty to oppose a reasonable measure that
only applies to a small part of one district, protects vulnerable
tenants, and pushes the city away from further automobile dependence.
It's insane that the mayor is expected to veto the bill. It's insane
that it's even an issue. And if the ordinance fails, it will be a sign
that even in San Francisco, in 2010, landlords, developers, and cars
are still king.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. 

Help build power for renters' rights: