Will Solar Energy Shine on Poor Communities?

Monday, September 14, 2015
Morgan Lee
San Diego Union-Tribune

A billion-dollar effort to bring more rooftop solar to multi-family housing projects in poor communities is among a raft of clean-energy remedies approved late last week by California lawmakers, and now awaiting the governor's signature.

As the legislative session ended, last-minute political wrangling focused primarily on aggressive new mandates for 2030 to double energy efficiency, generate half of California's energy from renewable sources like solar, and a defeated defeat an effort to cut petroleum consumption in half.

Tucked into several approved bills are provisions designed to address the relatively slow spread of rooftop solar within low-income communities and at multi-family housing complexes. For those solar projects, financial arrangements and risks are typically more complex than the single-family homeowner market, and the payoff from solar energy has not always trickled down to the electricity bills for individual tenants.

Assembly Bill 693 would devote up to $100 million a year to expanding rooftop solar at deed-restricted affordable housing complexes. Those dwellings are reserved for people living on less than 60 percent of the local area median income.

Scott Sarem, CEO of Carlsbad-based multi-tenant solar provider Everyday Energy, estimates the new solar program eventually could reach 200,000 low-income households if successful, offsetting individual utility bills in the process by 30 percent to 50 percent. (A longstanding subsidized multi-family solar program known as MASH has helped provide rooftop solar benefits to 6,771 multi-family dwellings in California as of June.)

Eligible low-income tenants in San Diego already receive a discount on electricity of 35 percent or more that is subsidized by other customers. Standard customers who foot the bill for those subsidies also stand to save money as solar energy offsets subsidized energy charges, said Sarem of Everyday.

"We ultimately are taking a huge burden off of all ratepayers through lessening the burden of CARE," said Sarem, referring to California Alternate Rates for Energy. CARE rates apply to about 30 percent of customers in San Diego Gas & Electric territory.

Multi-family property owners and independent solar developers also stand to benefit. Owners would offset their own energy bills for common areas, and might see lower vacancy rates as the financial strain eases on tenants. Developers like privately held Everyday Energy, and its sometime partner SolarCity, stand to grow their business while leveraging federal solar tax incentives.

Funding for the new multi-family solar incentive would come from California's greenhouse gas auction revenues, specifically pollution allowances that are allocated to electric utilities, sold off and returned to their customers in the form of clean energy projects and a twice-annual "climate credit" against electric bills.

Exact details of the Assembly Bill 693 program still need to be written by the California Public Utilities Commission, and might not move forward until 2017.

At the invitation of the commission, SDG&E has submitted its own proposal to jump-start rooftop solar installations in lagging areas.

SDG&E would invest $50 million toward developing and owning rooftop solar arrays on property leased from multi-family buildings and public schools over the next 25 years. Bill credits for the solar power would flow to tenants and families in the same community as the schools.

The utility would eventually recover revenues of $71 million from its "ratebase" of customers, much as it does with other infrastructure such as distribution wires and substations.

Critics of the utility proposal say it would reduce competition, potentially inflate costs and shrink solar bill credits to rooftop solar tenants.

Additional legislative provisions awaiting the governor's signature would direct the California Energy Commission to study current barriers to installing more clean energy and energy efficiency investments in low-income communities.

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: