Working Poor Grappling with Housing Crisis

Monday, March 16, 2015
Bill Silverfarb
San Mateo Daily Journal

Eloy Banuelos has a dream to send each of his six children to college.

It’s a dream that is stalled, however, as he grapples with decisions between feeding his family and paying his rent.

He lives in a one-bedroom apartment near downtown San Mateo with his wife, six children of various ages and now a grandson.

It’s a tight fit to say the least. The apartment is small as it is butwith nine people living there, they’ve gotten creative with the sleeping arrangements.

They’ve lived in the apartment for over a decade and the rent sat still at $1,400 a month for many years.

But then it went up to $1,500 and last year it went up twice. Banuelos now pays $1,900 a month for the apartment and prays it doesn’t go up any more.

If it does, the family will likely have to leave the area.

A 36 percent increase in rent the past two years is far beyond the pay raise he has received during the same period working as a janitor at Oracle.

He makes $42,000 a year and his wife, Rosa, works multiple jobs at restaurants in downtown San Mateo to help make ends meet.

Their daughter Erika, 21, attends classes at the College of San Mateo now but also works part time to help the family survive.

They simply can’t afford another rent increase and finding a landlord willing to rent to a family of nine is daunting.

“You need $10,000 in your pocket just to rent a new place,” said Banuelos, whose 19-year-old adult son also lives at home. “We need all the adults here to pay the rent.”

They do get some help from the county in the form of food stamps but after that they are all on their own.

Through attending St. Matthew Catholic Church in San Mateo, however, they have become involved in highlighting their personal plight through San Francisco Organizing Project/Peninsula Interfaith Action. The nonprofit has held rallies and marches throughout the area in recent months to decry increasing rents and the impact they have on the working poor. The group has urged cities and the county to build more affordable housing and to consider the needs of all the restaurant workers, drivers, janitors and other service workers who are not benefiting from the area’s technology boom.

According to San Mateo County officials, the average rent has jumped 51 percent in the past four years for a two-bedroom apartment at $2,648 a month.

The Board of Supervisors has labeled it a housing crisis and will meet in a special study session Tuesday to discuss what can be done to keep people in their homes.

SFOP/PIA has especially highlighted the conditions of immigrant families who work hard and take care of their children. The Banuelos family has neighbors downstairs with three separate families living in the same sized apartment they are.

It’s a reality many of the people they know face, Banuelos said.

“At least 80 percent of the people I know live like us,” he said.

Banuelos, 40, wants to be a part of this community. He wants to raise his children in good San Mateo schools and wants them to have more than he has.

He’s starting to become skeptical, however, that he can achieve his dreams.

“It’s embarrassing I’m poor,” he said.

Finding a second job is also difficult, he said, since he works on salary at Oracle and more than the typical 40-hour work week.

When he first came to this country more than 20 years ago from Mexico, the rents were reasonable, he said.

“Right now, it’s impossible,” he said about escalating rents. “We are being pushed out.”

Housing has become a crisis, according to SFOP/PIA, because individuals earning minimum wage must work over 117 hours a week to afford the average two-bedroom apartment in San Francisco.

While San Francisco has rent control, it only exists in San Mateo County in parts of East Palo Alto and at mobile-home parks in unincorporated county lands.

County Manager John Maltbie recommended to study rent stabilization in his mid-year budget report last month.

It’s not a popular topic with landlords and the groups paid to advocate for them, however, as the board has been urged to not study rent stabilization in the county.

But SFOP/PIA is urging the board to consider strategies to keep the working poor and immigrant families living close to where the work.

The board Tuesday will consider rent stabilization, tenants rights, amending zoning codes to ease construction of affordable housing and even the construction of tiny houses as a way to solve the housing crisis.

Banuelos, however, isn’t sure a tiny house will solve his family’s problems since the apartment they rent is already tiny enough. 

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. 

Help build power for renters' rights: