Time is running out for the residents of San Francisco’s Yerba Buena Island.
About 100 people in 40 households have until September to move off the island, making way for the construction of condos, a hotel and a ferry terminal. They’ve been given a choice: Move to an apartment on Treasure Island or accept a cash offer from the city to leave.
But residents aren’t happy with either option. They’re asking for relocation assistance until the development is complete and the opportunity to return to the island, though city officials say they signed away those rights in their leases.
As the eviction date inches closer, tenants continue to question why a city in the midst of an affordable housing crisis would replace their homes with market-rate condos. They’re paying $1,900 to $2,900 for two- to four-bedroom units, but the prices are expected to rise significantly once the development is complete.
Some residents are giving in and moving to more affordable, far-flung suburbs. Others are fighting to stay.
“It’s an end of an era, and I recognize that,” said Lisa Watts, a teacher who moved to Yerba Buena Island in 2000. “I remember standing in the parking lot and looking out over the ocean for the first time; I was sold. I’ll never be able to afford to live here again. I’m just so angry at this point that I don’t know what to do.”
The city has long planned to develop both Treasure Island and Yerba Buena Island. In 2011, the Board of Supervisors approved a 20-year redevelopment plan for Treasure Island, a former naval station, but the discovery of radiological and chemical contamination in the soil and a subsequent environmental analysis delayed construction.
Land transferred
The U.S. Navy has now transferred about 290 acres of property to the Treasure Island Development Authority — a nonprofit public benefit agency that oversees the economic development of the two islands. Smaller land transfers will follow over the next seven years.
TIDA approved the first of four phases of construction in May. During the first phase, which starts this fall, aging Navy buildings on Yerba Buena Island will be replaced with a hotel, a ferry terminal and 300 market-rate priced condos, 285 of which will be available for purchase in late 2018. The other 15 will be rented at a below-market cost.
In total, the development of the islands — a partnership between Lennar Urban, Kenwood Investments, Wilson Meany and Stockbridge Investments — is expected to cost roughly $1.5 billion and create up to 8,000 residences with more than 25 percent designated as affordable housing.
But Yerba Buena Island residents are quick to point out that only 5 percent of the 300 on their island are being offered as affordable.
“Once the construction is complete, they aren’t offering us anything to return to,” said Betty Mackey, who moved to Yerba Buena Island in 2004. She’s one of the biggest supporters of the “Save YBI” movement. “They gave us priority on market-rate housing, but who can afford a million-dollar condo? Not us. And the affordable housing? We would have to enter into a lottery to get it. The whole thing is completely unconscionable.”
Others, like Supervisor Jane Kim, argue that it shouldn’t matter where the affordable units are, as long as they exist.
“I understand that the Yerba Buena Island residents are taking this as a one-island-against-the-other sort of thing, but I always view it as one community,” she said. “In 2011 when we were making this plan, 25 percent was a good number. That’s a high amount of affordable housing, and that’s what matters, not where it’s located.”
Different islands
Residents are keenly aware of the disparities between the two islands. Yerba Buena Island has steep hills with sweeping views of downtown and the East Bay. Eucalyptus trees shade winding streets, and the environment is natural.
On Treasure Island — which is man-made and flat as a pancake — the landscape is exposed and has little vegetation. Chain-link fences cordon off derelict houses undergoing environmental remediation. Exposition Drive, the main thoroughfare, runs past rows of gray, cookie-cutter homes brightened by colorful front doors. Some have broken windows and cracked foundations.
Per TIDA’s Transitional Housing Rules and Regulations, replacement units for tenants are to be no less than 90 percent of the current square footage of their home and in similar upkeep. TIDA officials say the Yerba Buena Island tenants will be moved into homes similar to the ones they were in before.
“They’re kept up and all of the units are undergoing a thorough refurbishment before folks from Yerba Buena move in,” said Bob Beck, spokesman for TIDA. “They’ll move into a unit that has been freshly rehabbed with new paint, drywall and carpet.”
Unhappy with offer
But some households, who cannot afford to move anywhere else, are deeply suspicious. Evgeny Kulikov and his wife, Jivka Kulikova, Bulgarian immigrants, say they’re being offered a three-bedroom home with one shower. With three kids, one with ulcerative colitis, and Kulikova’s disabled mother, they’re not sure how it’s going to work out — right now they have a three-bedroom, two-bathroom unit.
“How is it possible for all of us to live with one shower?” Kulikov said. “It’s absolutely frustrating. I don’t know what we are going to do. We are just first-generation immigrants trying to make the American dream, and we can’t afford it.”
Other families would rather take the buyout — pretax, it’s roughly $5,550 for each adult, $3,700 for all children and an additional $3,700 for a disability — than move to Treasure Island.
“We were afraid of all the possible health issues that could arise on Treasure Island,” Tamara Farley said. She joined her boyfriend, Jon Cooksey, on the island four years ago. “Jameson wouldn’t have been able to dig in the dirt or play outside safely,” she said of their 1-year-old son. “They say it’s safe, but I don’t believe it. I didn’t want to bring a baby there.”
Last week, they boxed up their possessions, loaded their two cats and Jameson into the car and moved to Vallejo. It was emotional saying goodbye to their longtime home on Yerba Buena Road, Farley said. But after taxes, the payment was just enough for the family to put down a deposit and first month’s rent on a three-bedroom house.
“It’s just been a discouraging and heartbreaking process,” Farley said. “A working-class family can no longer afford to live in the city. It’s not like they’re just kicking us off the island. They’re kicking us out of the city, too.”
FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.